Tish Knobf, New Research for Cancer
Survivors
August 3, 2008
Welcome to Yale Cancer Center Answers with Dr. Ed Chu and Dr. Ken Miller. I am Bruce Barber. Dr. Chu is Deputy Director and Chief Of Medical Oncology at Yale Cancer Center and Dr. Miller is a Medical Oncologist specializing in pain and palliative care, and he also serves as the Director of the Connecticut Challenge Survivorship Clinic. If you would like to join the discussion you can contact the doctors directly at canceranswers@yale.edu or 1-888-234-4YCC. This evening Ed Chu is joined by Tish Knobf, the American Cancer Society Professor of Oncology Nursing at Yale University School of Nursing. Tish has focused much of her career in research on cancer survivorship and is a recipient of the Lance Armstrong Foundation Grant.
Chu
Tish, we are going to be talking for the most part today about
your research efforts in the field of cancer survivorship. But I
thought we could start off with some definitions for our listeners,
specifically the definition of a cancer survivor, which I
understand has evolved a little bit. There was a strict definition,
and now there is a broader definition. Could you help us define
survivorship?
Knobf
A survivor I think is how one individually appreciates it, but
basically the broad definition is anyone from the time of
diagnosis; anyone who has been diagnosed with cancer can be
perceived as a survivor. It has gotten more well-defined in terms
of how we deliver care to survivors, there are acute survivors, who
are patients in treatment, and then there is a recovery
rehabilitation phase for survivors who have been treated and who do
not have any evidence of their cancer. We need to try and help them
recover. Then there is extended survival, and that can patients who
live for years without the cancer coming back. There are survivors
for whom the cancer does come back, and who are receiving treatment
and/or palliative care.
Chu
In the 20 to 25 years that I have been in the field, and you
obviously also have had great experience in this field of cancer
treatment, but our ability to have the patient survive their cancer
diagnosis has dramatically improved.
Knobf
I think right now it is about 65% of all cancer patients live
longer than 5 years. There has been a real focus in the last 2 to 3
years on helping people transition who have finished therapy;
transition into life after cancer treatment and that is the focus
of my research, helping people to live a healthy life after the
cancer treatment is over.
Chu
How did you make the decision to focus in on that area for your
own research career?
Knobf
For most of my clinical and research career I worked with women
with breast cancer. I then became interested in how they deal with
the
symptoms during treatment, and doing that research opened by eyes to what it was like for them when treatment ended. The reality is that the symptoms do not go away when you get your last treatment, but, in fact, they persist for several months, if not, for some patients, years. That got me very interested in trying to understand what life was like after treatment and what could we do to make that life better.
Chu
That is a nice segway into the grant that you recently received
from the Lance Armstrong Foundation. Can you tell our listeners
what that proposal is all about?
Knobf
Lance Armstrong, as most listeners probably know, is very
interested in cancer survivors and recovery both physically and
psychologically after treatment. This past grant cycle for the
Lance Armstrong Foundation, they were very interested in programs
that would help people recover, and they were particularly
interested in programs that would help minority populations or
underserved populations. We have been working for about 3 to 4
years with a group of women of color in the New Haven area trying
to look at some of their unique needs and what we could be doing as
providers to help minority populations manage the effects of
cancer, and how they cope with that in their individual lives and
in their culture. This was really the foundation for Lance
Armstrong, to develop a program that would look at physical
activity and healthy eating choices in a population of women of
color who were cancer survivors.
Chu
There has been a great deal of research looking into the barriers
that women of color, and all minorities and underserved
populations, have with respect to say, Caucasians, in terms of
access to care and response to care. Are there also differences in
terms of the issue of cancer survivorship and how women of color
and other minority populations do once the cancer treatment has
been completed?
Knobf
The unique aspect that we discovered in our Connecting Sisters
project was the influence of their culture and how they grew up.
There is a very, very strong sisterhood bond and a very strong
relationship between how they cope with illness, particularly
cancer, and their faith. Not necessarily their alliance to a
particular church, but they have a very strong faith bond and they
have a very strong need to be connected with other women of color.
This project helped us identify support groups that were
specifically for women of color, because they have a smaller
incidence of breast cancer than the larger Caucasian population, so
it is a little more challenging to help them network with other
women of color. That is what the project, and also the Lance
Armstrong Foundation program, is going to do; help network them and
empower them in terms of healthy lifestyle
choices.
Chu
And what are some of those healthy lifestyle choices that you are
focusing on?
Knobf
What we will do in the Lance Armstrong Foundation Program is
provide a 6-week program that is based on the concepts of
sisterhood and social support, that is using the women to support
each other, and we will be giving them information on types of
physical activity, community resources and how they can use
community resources in order to develop a daily program of physical
activity. They will each be developing an individual sheet that
looks at what is going to prevent them from exercising everyday,
and what is going to help them and encourage them to identify a
partner, and develop a program that they can do at home in their
own neighborhood that will work for them. We will also be giving
them a cook book and will have 2 classes with a dietician to help
them make better choices for healthy eating.
Chu
Will they interface at all with an exercise physiologist or
physical therapists?
Knobf
Yes, we will have a physical therapist present at the classes who
will help them understand the exercises and they will all get
pedometers which will help them count their steps. The national
guideline is 10,000 steps a day, which I do not know how many
people have worn a pedometer, it is pretty challenging to get
10,000 steps.
Chu
10,000 steps, how far is that?
Knobf
I am not sure, but you start where ever you are, so if you have to
start at 2000, then you will be encouraged to keep a chart and see
if you can increase the number of steps per day. Cancer treatment
takes its toll on patients and they often do not keep up with their
normal activities. Many cancer patients during treatment become
de-conditioned so you have to start where they are and help them
gradually increase.
Chu
This program will be here at Yale-New Haven Hospital, Bridgeport
Hospital? Where will the centers be?
Knobf
Lance Armstrong Foundation is very committed to community programs
and so this particular grant mechanism was meant to have a program
that would be in more than one community. We have partnered with
Bridgeport Hospital and we have strong support from a program
called The Witness Project, which is African American Women who go
out and
get the message to their sisters about early detection and mammography. They are very interested in participating with us and offering this program to women of color in Bridgeport. We will be doing these programs in both cities, New Haven and Bridgeport.
Chu
Terrific. How good are women of color in terms of seeking followup
for their care? In terms of making sure that the cancer has not
come back and the usual ongoing routine health assessments.
Knobf
That is a difficult question, all of the research that has been
done so far speaks to educational and economic issues, and the
ability to get to the doctor's appointments. Women of color who are
well educated and have financial means probably have followup that
is identical to any other group of women. They are very concerned
about breast cancer risk to their other family members, and to
their daughters, and they are very avid about their followup. The
populations that we need to help make sure get to their followup
appointments are those who have less means in order to do it. Those
people that have competing life demands is the population we need
to help.
Chu
How does this support system work to help women during their
cancer treatment, not only for women of color, but for any woman
with breast cancer? What are the different types of support systems
that are available to them?
Knobf
During treatment women are very well supported. They see their
oncology nurses all the time, they talk to their oncologist all the
time, they are going to a health care facility where they perceive
that they are getting treatment to keep the cancer either away, or
in order to put it into remission. There are also social workers
and other providers who provide support during treatment. It is
when the treatment ends that we need to be developing
interventions, because our medical system normally sees cancer
patients every 3-6 months, so all of the support that was there
seems to disappear once the treatment ends. That is where we need
to develop programs or interventions to help people during those
vulnerable 6 to 9 months after treatment when they begin to think
about the consequences of the diagnosis and the treatment. They are
still living with feeling tired and they may have other symptoms
that have not gone away. They need some help dealing with their
anxieties, uncertainty and their physical symptoms as well.
Chu
It is interesting because both women patients and male patients
feel like they are part of the family when they come to the clinic
setting, but once
that treatments ends, it is sometimes like they have been abandoned and they feel lost.
Knobf
There is an article called "Cast Adrift" because patients feel
like they are sent out in this little rowboat by themselves once
treatment has ended. Their family wants them to get better, their
friends want them to get better, their coworkers want them to come
back to work if they've taken time off, their hair starts growing
back and they look healthier, but psychologically, and sometimes
physically too, it takes a much longer time to recover.
Chu
We would like to remind you to e-mail your questions to
canceranswers@yale.edu or call 1-888-234-4YCC. At this time we are
going to take a short break for medical minute. Please stay tuned
to learn more about the issues of cancer survivorship with my
special guest, Tish Knobf.
Chu
Welcome back to Yale Cancer Center Answers, this is Dr. Ed Chu and
I am here in the studio with my special guest, Tish Knobf, the
American Cancer Society Professor of Oncology Nursing here at Yale
School of Medicine and Yale Cancer Center. Before the break we were
talking about Tish's research focused on cancer survivorship in
women with breast cancer and the exciting work that she is doing
focusing on issues of cancer survivorship for women of color. She
recently received an award from the Lance Armstrong Foundation.
Tish, for those who did not hear the first segment of the show,
could you very quickly, recount what this grant is for the Lance
Armstrong Foundation and when is it going to begin?
Knobf
This is a 6-week program, and it is going to be 2 hours a week. It
is for women of color who have survived cancer and it will provide
information about breast cancer for women of color. The focus is
really going to be on how to develop a plan for daily physical
activity and healthy eating
choices. We will begin the program in September and we will be offering it in New Haven and Bridgeport. Anyone who is interested can call me directly at (203) 737-2357. We will be providing African American women with exercise physiologists who will be giving them classes on exercise and they will receive cookbooks on how to develop healthy eating meals at home with a dietician who specifically works with women of color. It will be a really fun program, so I hope you join us.
Chu
This sounds like an extremely important research effort that you
are putting together. Obviously you are focusing on women of color,
but the issues that you are identifying and dealing with relate to
all women with breast cancer, or any other cancer, I would
suspect.
Knobf
Yeah, I think so.
Chu
You also received a very large grant from the National Institute
of Health to study the effects and influence of exercise on cancer
survivorship. Can you tell our listeners a little bit more about
what that grant project is all about?
Knobf
That grant project is a year long study, and we know that there
are some effects of cancer treatment that persists after cancer
treatment is over. There are some effects, which we call late
effects, which may be side effects or consequences of the treatment
in the long term. One of the things that we are interested in is
relatively young, or young midlife women in the
45�55-year-old range, who will be going into menopause
either because of the cancer treatment, or just because it is a
natural time for them. There is an increased amount of bone loss in
the first five years that a woman goes into menopause, and it seems
there is a particularly greater risk for women who go into
menopause because of cancer treatment. We want to prevent that if
possible. Also, we want to help women maintain a healthy weight,
because we know that is important in certain cancer diagnoses like
breast cancer and colorectal cancer. We want to minimize women's
risks for other health risks such as heart disease and diabetes. It
is a program aimed at keeping cancer survivors healthy, not only
from a cancer coming back, but also from developing other kinds of
health risks as they age. This will be a study where there will be
two different types of exercise. It will be supervised exercise at
a fitness center, compared to a home-based exercise program. Both
groups will get information on nutrition and healthy eating and
both groups will also get supplements of vitamin D and calcium;
both of which are very important to bone health.
Chu
I would imagine an expert exercise physiologist is also involved
in this project.
Knobf
Yes, we have two co-investigators who have doctoral degrees in
exercise physiology. Our staff also consists of exercise
physiologists and our interventionist will be trained in exercise
science and monitoring the subjects in this study.
Chu
So it is not like people have to go out and be able to run 2 or 3
miles or a marathon, but to have daily constant physical activity
in order to help prevent all those bad things from recurring.
Knobf
Right, both groups will get very specific instructions and
information about the types of moderate physical activity. The
current national guideline is 30 minutes of moderate activity on
most days of the week. Moderate activity is something like brisk
walking, not casual slow walking, but brisk walking. We will give
them examples of moderate activity and the supervised group will
get very specific information about which exercises to do and how
often.
Chu
This is probably a good recommendation for anyone, with or without
cancer, because this is a part of good healthy living.
Knobf
It is a part of good healthy living, but if we took a survey of
all of our listeners I doubt that most of our listeners are
exercising 30 minutes on most days of the week. It is forcing me to
become a role model.
Chu
No need to go to the listeners, I think yours truly has also
clearly fallen very short of that national goal.
Knobf
It is important now in cancer though because we do have 2 or 3
studies with at least initial evidence that even walking 30 minutes
on 3 or more days of the week has an association with lower risks
of recurrence and a better survival. There were 3 studies in breast
and in colorectal cancer patients.
Chu
How many women do you hope to enroll into this study?
Knobf
We hope to enroll 150 women. There will be 75 women in each group
of the 2 different exercise programs.
Chu
Will all of these women have been treated here at Yale Cancer
Center, or will they come from different communities in the
state?
Knobf
They will come from both Yale Cancer Center and areas throughout
probably the greater New Haven area.
Chu
How will you reach out and identify potential study
participants?
Knobf
We will use both hospitals in New Haven, Yale-New Haven Hospital
and the Hospital of St. Raphael. In our previous studies one of the
most successful strategies has been making women in the community
aware. We will do community announcements in the local papers
because it will attract the women who are interested. Providers,
physicians and nurses are always willing to help us identify
patients, but cancer survivors as individuals are the ones who are
most motivated to want to do this.
Chu
For women who do not join your study, but have had breast cancer
and undergone treatment and who are cancer survivors that are
scared or anxious about this notion of starting an exercise program
at home, what can they do to jump start things and get involved in
an exercise program?
Knobf
The American Cancer Society has a couple of wonderful booklets.
One is called "Smart Steps" which gives you lots of ideas of how to
slowly begin an exercise program. For cancer patients who have the
ability and the financial means, they could certainly join a
fitness center. The other resource would be the Survivorship Clinic
at Yale where we have an exercise physiologist who can provide
information and consultation.
Chu
Tish, could you speak a little bit more about the Survivorship
Clinic here at Yale and what the different recourses available to
cancer survivors are?
Knobf
At the Survivorship Clinic here there is a comprehensive
evaluation, so survivors can get a comprehensive summary of what
their treatment has been, what their followup should be and what
potential side effects of treatment should be monitored more
closely. For instance, if somebody had radiation therapy to the
chest, or if they got an anthracycline drug, their cardiac status
should be monitored more closely than someone who did not. There
are multiple services provided at the Survivorship Clinic. There is
a social worker, a dietitian, an exercise physiologist and multiple
resources are identified for survivors to help them and their
families cope and manage life after cancer treatment.
Chu
It is a terrific clinic and we have been very, very fortunate to
have this philanthropic group, the Connecticut Challenge, led by
their founder and spiritual leader, Jeff Keith, to help raise money
on behalf of the Survivorship Clinic. Their efforts are now
expanded into trying to support research efforts into cancer
survivorship.
Knobf
When you think of a bicyclist, you always think of Lance
Armstrong, but what has been most exciting about the Connecticut
Challenge is that it has put survivorship on the map, or on the
front page of the paper, for survivors. It has increased awareness
for people with cancer, and without cancer. For our listeners who
do not have a cancer diagnosis, but might be at risk or might have
a family member that has cancer, that message of people now
surviving for years and years after cancer treatment because of the
advances in our treatment is such an important message.
Chu
Absolutely. Tish, you have been in the field for a long time and
have been involved in research, but now your focus is on cancer
survivorship, which is a relatively new area of research. Where do
you see the field evolving to over the next 5 to 10 years?
Knobf
I think the focus is going to continue to be on followup after
treatment and also long-term followup. There are four major areas
of survivorship care identified by the Institute of Medicine. One
is prevention; prevention of recurrence of the cancer or a new
cancer. The second is surveillance; what kind of guidelines do we
have for people who are to have followup, how long should they have
followup? Intervention is the third one which is my area of
research, which is managing potential or actual side effects of
cancer treatment. The fourth and final area in survivorship care is
how to coordinate our medical care system. We have so many
survivors now; we need to figure out how they are going to be taken
care of by their oncologist or by their primary care physician.
This is the map that the Institute of Medicine has put out for us
to look at in regards to how do we take care of people once they
have been diagnosed and treated for cancer?
Chu
Tish, the time has gone pretty quickly and I would like to thank
you for joining me this evening on Yale Cancer Center Answers.
Congratulations on receiving those two large grants from the Lance
Armstrong Foundation and from the National Institute of Health. We
certainly look forward to having you come back to hear the outcomes
of your research projects. Until next week, this is Dr. Ed Chu from
the Yale Cancer Center wishing you a safe and healthy week.