Advances in Lung Cancer
March 29, 2021Information
March 28, 2021
Yale Cancer Center
visit: http://www.yalecancercenter.org
email: canceranswers@yale.edu
call: 203-785-4095
ID6351
To CiteDCA Citation Guide
- 00:00Support for Yale Cancer Answers
- 00:02comes from AstraZeneca, dedicated
- 00:05to advancing options and providing
- 00:07hope for people living with cancer.
- 00:10More information at astrazeneca-us.com.
- 00:14Welcome to Yale Cancer
- 00:16Answers with your host,
- 00:17Doctor Anees Chagpar. Yale Cancer Answers
- 00:20features the latest information on
- 00:22cancer care by welcoming oncologists and
- 00:24specialists who are on the forefront of
- 00:26the battle to fight cancer. This week,
- 00:28it's a conversation about lung
- 00:30cancer with Doctor Roy Herbst.
- 00:32Doctor Herbst is
- 00:33Ensign Professor of Medicine
- 00:34and medical Oncology,
- 00:35an professor of pharmacology at
- 00:37the Yale School of Medicine,
- 00:39where Doctor Chagpar is a
- 00:42professor of surgical oncology.
- 00:44Maybe we can start off by talking
- 00:47a little bit about the Epidemiology
- 00:49of lung cancer, is it still
- 00:51one of the leading
- 00:53cancers and the leading
- 00:55cause of cancer related death?
- 00:57Lung cancer still is
- 00:59unfortunately the number one cause of cancer
- 01:02death worldwide with maybe 1.6, 1.7
- 01:04deaths a year by incidence.
- 01:06It's not the number one cancer diagnosed
- 01:09more breast cancer is diagnosed in women,
- 01:12and prostate cancer in men,
- 01:13but by death, it certainly is the major
- 01:16killer because it tends to present in
- 01:19a metastatic way, already having spread.
- 01:21But you know, we're making great inroads
- 01:24now with early screening for lung cancer
- 01:26and hopefully will find it earlier.
- 01:29And we have seen improvements in
- 01:31survival but there is still work to do.
- 01:33I wanted to start off there and
- 01:36certainly will get into some of the recent
- 01:38advances in screening and treatment.
- 01:41But you know, lung cancer used to be
- 01:43the number one cancer, and we saw that
- 01:46breast cancer and prostate cancer kind
- 01:49of pulled ahead several years ago.
- 01:52And in part, I think that that was
- 01:54related to some advances that were
- 01:57made in terms of lung cancer.
- 01:59Primary prevention.
- 02:00In other words,
- 02:01not getting lung cancer to begin with.
- 02:04Do you want to kind of talk
- 02:07about some of that?
- 02:08Particularly where it
- 02:10pertains to smoking cessation?
- 02:12Right, the best way to
- 02:15treat lung cancer still is to prevent it,
- 02:18and certainly even though there
- 02:19is a very real group of patients
- 02:22with a non smoking lung cancer,
- 02:24as many as 15% or more of patients in the
- 02:27United States about double that in Asia,
- 02:30still smoking is one of the primary
- 02:33reasons for causation and lung cancer.
- 02:35So major efforts have been underway over
- 02:37the last 50-60 years in the United States
- 02:40since the initial Surgeon General's report
- 02:42to stem the tide of smoking.
- 02:45We've gone down from 50% of Americans
- 02:48smoking, perhaps to less than 20%,
- 02:50maybe 18% or so,
- 02:51differing among different groups
- 02:53in different states,
- 02:54but we still need to do better.
- 02:56But smoking clearly is a cause and now we
- 02:59worry as we've really worked on smoking
- 03:02both with education and
- 03:04with medications, with counseling.
- 03:05Now we see this big surge in E-
- 03:08cigarette use and we worry and I'm
- 03:10very involved with the American
- 03:12Association of Cancer Research, actually.
- 03:15The task force on tobacco control.
- 03:17We're actually looking very carefully
- 03:19at E-cigarettes because we worry
- 03:21that these are being used now by
- 03:23children and young adults
- 03:25and they're filled with nicotine,
- 03:26and nicotine is the addictive
- 03:28substance in cigarettes,
- 03:29so people are getting addicted to nicotine.
- 03:31And then they go to what's
- 03:33called dual use and start to use
- 03:35combustible cigarettes, the
- 03:37type we're most familiar with.
- 03:38And then of course
- 03:40the story is all too familiar,
- 03:42and this is important
- 03:45to tell you here in New Haven where we live
- 03:48the rates are probably a
- 03:50bit higher than the national average
- 03:53and we're doing a lot of work
- 03:56with community programs
- 03:58as part of our long funded research
- 04:01through the National Cancer Institute,
- 04:03we just completed a large trial when
- 04:06patients came into the hospital,
- 04:08some with problems, some for screening.
- 04:10We tried to use new methods to help them
- 04:13to stop smoking, new messaging tools,
- 04:16so that's still such an important part
- 04:18of this field to not smoke also we have
- 04:21to worry about other risk factors.
- 04:24Asbestos,
- 04:25radon gas is something we all
- 04:27think about here
- 04:28living in Connecticut,
- 04:29all these things can be a risk
- 04:31factor for future development of this
- 04:34disease. So I want to pick up on a couple
- 04:37of things that you said just quickly.
- 04:39So the first was your study looking
- 04:42at new messaging techniques.
- 04:47Roughly 20% of the population smoke
- 04:50and for many of them it is
- 04:53very difficult to quit.
- 04:55There are all kinds of things out there.
- 04:58There's quitlines,
- 04:59there's patches, there's gum,
- 05:00there's behavioral modification.
- 05:01Some people even advocate
- 05:03paying people to quit smoking,
- 05:05and some people are even suggesting
- 05:08that E cigarettes can be used as a
- 05:11bridge to help people to quit smoking.
- 05:13So for our listeners out there,
- 05:16the 20% who may be smoking
- 05:19as they listen to this,
- 05:21what's the best way to quit and
- 05:23where can they get help?
- 05:24Well, first of all,
- 05:25I would definitely ask for help.
- 05:27That could be your physician.
- 05:29That could be a nurse practitioner.
- 05:30Just whoever you see for
- 05:32your regular health checks.
- 05:33Some of these quit lines
- 05:34can be extremely helpful,
- 05:36and there are a number of
- 05:37ways to work on quitting,
- 05:39and now this is an addiction
- 05:40and it is hard to quit,
- 05:42especially if you've been using
- 05:44cigarettes for a long time.
- 05:45The nicotine is really hard to beat,
- 05:47so there are a couple of ways to do it
- 05:50here in our smoking cessation clinic,
- 05:52they will assess each person
- 05:54on an individual basis.
- 05:55There are certainly ways to substitute
- 05:57for the nicotine other than a
- 05:59combustible cigarette that you smoke.
- 06:02There are certain medications that can help,
- 06:05but then of course,
- 06:06behavioral modification and counseling,
- 06:07which I think is so important here at Yale,
- 06:10where we have an amazing center of
- 06:12emotional intelligence and there
- 06:14have been studies done to show
- 06:16that different types of messaging
- 06:17can be more effective than others.
- 06:19For example,
- 06:20many of you have seen
- 06:22cigarette cartoons.
- 06:23Not so much in the United States,
- 06:25but around the world where there
- 06:27are these horrible images of people
- 06:28and the consequences of smoking.
- 06:30Those are very negative type messages,
- 06:32but they're intended to scare
- 06:33people from not smoking.
- 06:34There's been some thought that more
- 06:36gain framed messaging where you
- 06:38might show well if you don't smoke,
- 06:40you'll feel better if you don't smoke,
- 06:42your skin will look better.
- 06:43That could be another way of doing it.
- 06:45We're testing some of those
- 06:47new methods here at Yale.
- 06:48The other thing we've done
- 06:49is a biofeedback approach,
- 06:50so we actually have an infrared
- 06:53device that can measure carotenoids
- 06:54in the skin and the health of the
- 06:57skin which we know actually can
- 06:59get somewhat destroyed with tobacco
- 07:01use and we actually are using that
- 07:03sort of biofeedback with patients to
- 07:05try to maintain them from using tobacco.
- 07:08So we've been working very hard on this.
- 07:10Lisa Fucito leads this effort now
- 07:12in our clinic and we're trying to
- 07:15serve as many patients as possible.
- 07:17And by the way,
- 07:18it's not just lung cancer.
- 07:20About 20 different cancers that
- 07:22all can trace their
- 07:23origin back to smoking and
- 07:25we are really trying to work on this.
- 07:27It's something that's now as
- 07:28part of our medical record.
- 07:30Everyone's asked the question
- 07:31about tobacco use.
- 07:32And primary prevention is just so important,
- 07:34but even if someone has smoked
- 07:36and many people have and they
- 07:37stopped they are still at risk
- 07:39of developing lung
- 07:40cancer and this is where screening
- 07:42comes in and the idea
- 07:44that you can do a low dose CAT
- 07:47scan to screen for lung cancer.
- 07:48And I'm very proud to say that
- 07:50even during this very difficult
- 07:52year with covid and clinics
- 07:53closed or moved,
- 07:54we've actually had a very strong
- 07:56year number wise in the
- 07:58number of patients in the
- 08:00area that we've screened.
- 08:06So screening patients and
- 08:07finding cancers early in people
- 08:09at high risk is also a very
- 08:11important tool that we're using.
- 08:14I think the last question
- 08:16before we move on from smoking
- 08:19cessation is I wanted to get
- 08:20your thoughts on taxation.
- 08:22So certainly in
- 08:23some parts of the world they've
- 08:26found that making
- 08:28it hurt in people's pocketbooks
- 08:31is often a deterrent to smoking.
- 08:34Where do you come down on that?
- 08:38Do you advocate that governments
- 08:40should put stiff taxes on cigarette
- 08:42purchases to make that less appealing?
- 08:46Well, that a
- 08:48tough one. You know,
- 08:49different states do different things.
- 08:51I still remember once being in a drug
- 08:53store in New York City and someone
- 08:55came in for a pack of cigarettes.
- 08:58And it could cost up to $15-20
- 09:00with some of the different taxes and
- 09:04I think people will find the cigarettes
- 09:07elsewhere.
- 09:09I think it's a useful technique but it would have
- 09:11to be a universal sort of technique.
- 09:13Otherwise people will find
- 09:15ways of getting cigarettes.
- 09:16I'm much more
- 09:17in favor of
- 09:18some of the approaches I mentioned,
- 09:20whether it be counseling, medications.
- 09:24I think that the E cigarettes as
- 09:25a substitute for someone who's
- 09:27tried everything else could
- 09:28work in that way,
- 09:30but it has to be studied in a regulated way.
- 09:33You know there needs to be a clinical
- 09:35trial and we're actually trying to do
- 09:37some of those here right now at Yale,
- 09:40especially now with some of the
- 09:41covid regulations.
- 09:42But it would be nice to see if we can
- 09:45use these cigarettes in a measured way.
- 09:47With a prescribed dose,
- 09:48as a tool, but
- 09:52there are other forms of
- 09:54nicotine replacement,
- 09:54but clearly stopping people from
- 09:56smoking whatever method is used
- 10:00because it's a National emergency
- 10:02despite the fact that it's
- 10:04so much better than it was
- 10:06Really the only good level of
- 10:08tobacco use is none.
- 10:11And you worry also about the E cigarettes
- 10:14being yet another addictive substance
- 10:16and we don't really know long term what
- 10:19the health consequences are of that.
- 10:21The other thing that you mentioned was that
- 10:24there are many lung cancers that happen
- 10:27for reasons outside of cigarette smoking.
- 10:30For example, you mentioned in Asia
- 10:33about 50% of lung cancers are
- 10:35not related to cigarette smoking,
- 10:38and I wonder whether you think
- 10:40that there are some environmental
- 10:43issues that we need to consider.
- 10:46I mean is this part of
- 10:49the pollution that
- 10:51we're seeing in terms of
- 10:56manufacturing and so on that might be
- 10:58greater in some industrialized parts
- 11:00of Asia that promotes lung cancer.
- 11:03Or do we not know why there's these
- 11:07disparities?
- 11:09We're talking about the non smoking lung
- 11:11cancer which initially was due to
- 11:14the epidermal growth factor receptor
- 11:16mutation that was discovered more
- 11:18than 20 years ago and those levels are
- 11:21much higher in Asia than in the US.
- 11:24About double. 30 to 40% versus 15 to 20%.
- 11:28I don't know that it's environment
- 11:29because if someone is born in
- 11:31Asia and moves to Southern California,
- 11:33it seems like they have the same higher risk.
- 11:36So I think there's something genetic
- 11:39which amazes me with all the
- 11:41tools we have now to sequence
- 11:43genomes and we can sequence
- 11:46dozens and dozens of patients each day.
- 11:48We still have not found what
- 11:50the link there is.
- 11:52What is the genetic factor?
- 11:53It's being looked at quite intensively.
- 11:55It's this cooperation between
- 11:57researchers around the world.
- 11:58But we still don't know exactly
- 12:00why these mutations in epidermal
- 12:02growth factor receptor are so much
- 12:03more common in Asia than the US,
- 12:05but we're looking for it and
- 12:08learning how to treat that type of
- 12:10cancer with oral agents.
- 12:12It's actually been historic.
- 12:13I think that's part of the
- 12:15reason we're seeing
- 12:16a couple percent a year decreases in the
- 12:19death rates from lung cancer because
- 12:20of what we call targeted therapy.
- 12:22But even when those drugs work,
- 12:24as you know, patients will become resistant.
- 12:27That's actually something we're
- 12:28studying very much here in our group. NOTE Confidence: 0.8304425
- 12:30Katie Politi and Sarah Goldberg
- 12:32and Mark Lemon actually is one
- 12:35of the projects on our big lung
- 12:37Spore Grant looking
- 12:38at mechanisms of sensitivity and
- 12:40resistance to these drugs so that
- 12:42we can help more patients develop
- 12:44newer and better,
- 12:45more effective and
- 12:46less toxic ways to treat this disease.
- 12:49Yeah, and as
- 12:52we kind of think about lung
- 12:54cancer and the fact that it no
- 12:56longer is the number one cancer
- 12:58in people thanks to reduction in
- 13:00smoking cessation and other things,
- 13:02it still remains the number one
- 13:05killer in terms of being the number
- 13:08one cause of cancer related morbidity
- 13:10and mortality. Has that reduced in
- 13:13recent years thanks to some of the
- 13:15things that we'll be talking about in
- 13:18terms of understanding the genomics
- 13:20and tailored therapy and so on.
- 13:22Are we seeing the needle move?
- 13:24Oh absolutely, and I've seen this myself,
- 13:27so I started working in this field
- 13:30about 20-25 years ago as a young fellow
- 13:33at Dana
- 13:35Farber Cancer Institute actually,
- 13:36and no one even wanted to work in this field.
- 13:40Back then, it was really a death sentence
- 13:41if you had lung cancer,
- 13:44we had surgery and radiation techniques,
- 13:46but if it had spread
- 13:48the chemotherapy was OK,
- 13:49but really didn't do much.
- 13:51And I think over the years
- 13:53we've really taken the five year
- 13:55overall survival for lung cancer,
- 13:56which was in the low teens 10-11%.
- 13:59And now it's as high as 19% or more.
- 14:02Now that's all across all stages,
- 14:04stage 1,2,3 and four.
- 14:06Four being the most advanced,
- 14:07but that's progress.
- 14:08But the real progress that we're
- 14:10seeing is identifying a more
- 14:12personalized approach to this disease
- 14:14and learning how to treat it with
- 14:16some of these new targeted therapies.
- 14:18Learning how to treat it with immunotherapy.
- 14:20And yeah,
- 14:21I've seen
- 14:23patients now in 2021
- 14:26who now
- 14:30come here to our clinics
- 14:33and they either get standard
- 14:34of care or clinical trials.
- 14:36And a smaller proportion increasing
- 14:37every day are doing better,
- 14:39so there is definitely progress
- 14:41visible progress in this field.
- 14:42And understanding the science,
- 14:46what drives the lung cancer,
- 14:48what's causing it to grow and how
- 14:50to treat it in more effective ways.
- 14:53We're going to talk all about
- 14:55that right after we take a short
- 14:57break for a medical minute.
- 14:58Please stay tuned to learn
- 15:00more with my guest. Doctor
- 15:02Roy Herbst. Support for Yale Cancer
- 15:04Answers comes from AstraZeneca working
- 15:06to eliminate cancer as a cause of death.
- 15:08Learnmore@astrazeneca-us.com. This
- 15:14is a medical minute about genetic
- 15:17testing which can be useful for
- 15:19people with certain types of cancer
- 15:22that seem to run in their families.
- 15:24Patients that are considered at risk
- 15:27receive genetic counseling and testing so
- 15:29informed medical decisions can be based
- 15:32on their own personal risk assessment.
- 15:34Resources for genetic counseling and
- 15:36testing are available at federally
- 15:38designated comprehensive cancer centers.
- 15:40Interdisciplinary teams include geneticists,
- 15:42genetic counselors, physicians,
- 15:43and nurses
- 15:44who work together to provide
- 15:46risk assessment and steps to prevent
- 15:49the development of cancer.
- 15:50More information is available
- 15:52at yalecancercenter.org.
- 15:53You're listening to Connecticut Public Radio.
- 15:57Welcome back to Yale Cancer Answers.
- 16:00This is doctor Anees Chagpar and I'm
- 16:03joined tonight by my guest Doctor Roy Herbst.
- 16:06We're talking about recent advances in the
- 16:09management of lung cancer patients and Roy,
- 16:12right before the break you were telling
- 16:14us that you have seen visible progress in
- 16:18terms of reducing lung cancer mortality.
- 16:20This remains the number one cancer
- 16:23killer of Americans, both men and women,
- 16:26but we're seeing progress.
- 16:28So there are so many different avenues
- 16:30that we've seen in terms of lung cancer
- 16:34management that have contributed to this.
- 16:36What do you think is the greatest
- 16:39driver?
- 16:42The ACS announced earlier this year a 2% decrease
- 16:45in deaths from lung cancer since 2013.
- 16:48So clearly something's happening.
- 16:49I think part of it is the prevention,
- 16:53either primary prevention by avoiding
- 16:55smoking and other toxins, or the screening.
- 16:58But I have to believe a lot of
- 17:00it's been the therapies that we've
- 17:02seen in the last several years.
- 17:05Understanding the molecular
- 17:06basis of this disease.
- 17:10That's not really true.
- 17:13Everyone's cancer is a little bit different,
- 17:15caused by a different mechanism,
- 17:17a different genetic background.
- 17:18So now what we're doing is we're
- 17:21taking the patients cancer and we're
- 17:23performing molecular techniques
- 17:24for sequencing.
- 17:24We're looking at what makes it tick now.
- 17:27What is driving that cancer?
- 17:29And now there are about seven or
- 17:31eight different different mutations,
- 17:32different markers that we
- 17:34can then pair with a specific drug.
- 17:36So we're personalizing the therapy,
- 17:38and that's nice
- 17:39because these are oral therapies,
- 17:40that you take by mouth and are
- 17:43much less toxic than the
- 17:45chemotherapy we used to use,
- 17:46and we see the tumors shrink in
- 17:48a large percentage of patients.
- 17:50So many of these started
- 17:51out as clinical trials,
- 17:53and now they're moving
- 17:54forward to standard of care.
- 17:55So I think that's having a great benefit.
- 17:58I've seen it myself.
- 17:59Over the last 15-20 years,
- 18:00certainly within the last decade,
- 18:02many approved drugs in this space,
- 18:04so you really want to make sure
- 18:06that your cancer is analyzed in
- 18:07this way so that you have access
- 18:09to these drugs now.
- 18:11Like everything else,
- 18:12nothing is perfect with time
- 18:13the tumor will get smart and learn
- 18:15how to override these blockages.
- 18:17But that's why we're doing research.
- 18:19All of us that are at different
- 18:21centers to try to figure out
- 18:22one of the next steps and,
- 18:24and we're continuing to raise the bar,
- 18:26but that's certainly been
- 18:27one of the major advances.
- 18:29The second has been immunotherapy,
- 18:31and the idea that we can
- 18:33use the body's own immune system
- 18:34to attack the cancer really began
- 18:37in Melanoma and kidney cancer.
- 18:38But lung cancer being so common,
- 18:40we're seeing just amazing
- 18:42results that we can now actually
- 18:44take a cancer that's already spread
- 18:46throughout the body and we can treat
- 18:49with one of these immunotherapy drugs.
- 18:50And we're doing that now.
- 18:52And when we do that,
- 18:54actually in about 20% of
- 18:56the patients we see
- 18:57amazing results and the rest
- 18:58sometimes we see some
- 19:00activity and others we don't,
- 19:02so we have to do a little bit more,
- 19:04but these are patients who never
- 19:06before would have had any hope of
- 19:08doing well on some of these therapies.
- 19:10And then if that all was not enough,
- 19:12we're taking all these therapies
- 19:14that work in the most advanced
- 19:15stages and we're moving them
- 19:17earlier and earlier in disease.
- 19:19I can tell you one
- 19:20thing that I've seen
- 19:21over my career is the best drugs
- 19:23work best when they are used in the
- 19:26earliest possible stage after surgery,
- 19:27when the burden of lung cancer is the lowest.
- 19:30So now we're doing what's
- 19:32called adjuvent therapy,
- 19:33and I was very fortunate to actually
- 19:35present last year
- 19:37some data where an EGFR inhibitor used
- 19:39after surgery had really high impact
- 19:41on how patients did after that surgery,
- 19:44so the sky is the limit.
- 19:46Research in this area is paying off.
- 19:48We're seeing tangible benefits,
- 19:49but when I could also say and tell you,
- 19:52I'm sure many listening to this
- 19:54notice from their own experience,
- 19:56we still have to do even better,
- 19:58and that's why research, science,
- 20:00operative work working together
- 20:02is going to be so important,
- 20:04and that's the type of programs that
- 20:06we lead here at our center.
- 20:08Roy, let's dig into a few things
- 20:11that you talked about.
- 20:13So the first was targeted
- 20:15therapy and Genomics,
- 20:16and we've talked a lot on this show
- 20:19about kind of unpacking that concept
- 20:22in a variety of different cancers.
- 20:24and really trying to figure out what
- 20:27are the main drivers in lung cancer,
- 20:30so are all lung cancers kind
- 20:33of profiled in this way?
- 20:35And are there particular mutations that
- 20:37have druggable targets that you look for?
- 20:41Well, certainly all lung cancers
- 20:43when they've already spread
- 20:44from the lungs are what we
- 20:46call non squamous lung cancers,
- 20:48which the majority should
- 20:49be profiled in this way.
- 20:51And actually it's my belief we actually
- 20:53should probably profile all of them
- 20:55to understand one of the
- 20:57determinants that are causing that
- 20:59cancer to grow because that will allow
- 21:01us to match with the best therapy.
- 21:03Now I'm concerned you know one
- 21:05of the big issues we have is
- 21:07access to care and making sure all
- 21:09patients get this screening done.
- 21:11One thing we're doing a lot
- 21:14of work on is to try to get navigators
- 21:17out to all the different areas of the city
- 21:20to build trust.
- 21:22Within Connecticut we want every patient
- 21:24to have access to coming to a center
- 21:27where they can have their tumor profiled.
- 21:29But yes,
- 21:30if you profile the tumor,
- 21:31there's probably as much as a
- 21:3320% chance you'll find something
- 21:35that will allow you to match
- 21:37that patient with an oral drug,
- 21:39which in my opinion is certainly preferable
- 21:40to giving a nonspecific chemotherapy,
- 21:43so that's a huge advance.
- 21:44And we're continuing to find more of
- 21:46these and new combinations that can be used.
- 21:49So yes,
- 21:50that's what we call precision guided
- 21:52therapy and for the patients who
- 21:54don't have one of these mutations,
- 21:57do they get standard chemotherapy
- 21:59and have there been any advances
- 22:01in terms of standard chemotherapy
- 22:04for those people who either don't
- 22:06have a druggable target or who have
- 22:09a druggable target, and who recur?
- 22:11Well, incredibly, the
- 22:12answer is yes.
- 22:13So I mentioned immunotherapy already.
- 22:15So if someone does not
- 22:17have one of those targets,
- 22:19we actually can look for another target,
- 22:22something called PDL1,
- 22:23now PDL1 actually was in part
- 22:26discovered by Lieping Chen, NOTE Confidence: 0.80644786
- 22:28a professor here at Yale,
- 22:30and he's one of our collaborators,
- 22:32but we actually can measure
- 22:34PDL one and tumors.
- 22:35And if the level is very high,
- 22:37that tells us that the
- 22:39immunotherapy might work alone.
- 22:40So we give those patients immunotherapy,
- 22:43assuming they don't have
- 22:44some reason we can't.
- 22:45Sometimes you can't reactivate the
- 22:47immune system because someone might
- 22:49already have some bad arthritis or
- 22:51know what we call an autoimmune
- 22:53disease that precludes that.
- 22:54But for the rest of these, again,
- 22:56unless they have a contraindication,
- 22:58we're giving immunotherapy in
- 22:59combination with chemotherapy.
- 23:00Would have been what I would have
- 23:03guessed would have been such an active
- 23:05therapy, but for whatever reason,
- 23:07when you give chemotherapy
- 23:08and immunotherapy together,
- 23:09you at least have an additive effect,
- 23:11meaning the chemotherapy kills
- 23:13some of the tumor cells,
- 23:14releases some of the proteins
- 23:16that activate the immune system,
- 23:18and then use these drugs that
- 23:19we call a checkpoint
- 23:21inhibitor that unleash the power
- 23:23of the immune system and that's
- 23:25become a standard of therapy.
- 23:26Now I'll tell you that
- 23:28those results are really
- 23:30good and much better than
- 23:32what we've had in the past.
- 23:33But in my opinion we still
- 23:35have to raise the bar,
- 23:37so that's where clinical trials come in,
- 23:39and it would be my my big hope that
- 23:41in that room when a patient and a
- 23:44physician or nurse practitioner or
- 23:45whoever is there are meeting. someone
- 23:48brings up, is there a clinical trial?
- 23:50Is there something new that's
- 23:52looking at a new agent?
- 23:53A new drug,
- 23:54something that might even be more active?
- 23:56And of course,
- 23:57that's investigation,
- 23:58but that's really how we
- 24:00continue to do better and better,
- 24:03and we're inching up the
- 24:06benefits from therapy in lung cancer.
- 24:11So certainly clinical trials.
- 24:13I mean, we've talked on this show a
- 24:16lot about clinical trials and the
- 24:18fact that people who participate
- 24:20in clinical trials tend to do
- 24:22better than people who don't.
- 24:24Are all of the clinical trials in
- 24:27lung cancer now really geared around
- 24:29targeted therapies and immunooncology
- 24:32or are there any clinical trials that
- 24:35are looking at advances in standard
- 24:38chemotherapy for people who may not
- 24:40be eligible for those other therapies?
- 24:43Either because they don't have a
- 24:46target or because they don't have
- 24:49a tumor that's expressing PDL 1.
- 24:52Well, standard chemotherapy
- 24:53clearly has its place,
- 24:55and certainly in earlier stages of
- 24:57disease before the tumors have spread
- 24:59from the lung we're using chemotherapy
- 25:01with radiation therapy, for example,
- 25:03and that can be curative therapy.
- 25:05We often add immunotherapy in afterwards,
- 25:08but I actually personally think
- 25:09we've pretty much come as far
- 25:12as we can with chemotherapy.
- 25:14It's somewhat nonspecific.
- 25:15It can have a number of side effects.
- 25:18However, we're finding new
- 25:19targets like right now,
- 25:21just in the last several months,
- 25:23there's been data on a new target
- 25:26against something called Kras.
- 25:28Now Kras, which is an oncogene,
- 25:30actually first came from a rat model.
- 25:34Kras actually is about
- 25:3612 to 20% of lung tumors.
- 25:38The actual variant of this that
- 25:40now has multiple drugs that are
- 25:42out there is what we call G12C.
- 25:45Probably doesn't mean much to a
- 25:47lot of those who are listening,
- 25:49but it's a specific abnormality that
- 25:52occurs in 12% of lung cancer patients.
- 25:54That's a lot of patients.
- 25:56Remember,
- 25:56I told you it's 1.6, 1.7
- 25:58worldwide and there are actually agents now,
- 26:00not approved yet,
- 26:01but that are in clinical trials
- 26:03showing positive results that
- 26:04can make those tumors shrink.
- 26:06So before I pull off some chemotherapy,
- 26:08which by the way we will do and
- 26:09we do need to use and sometimes we
- 26:12even use it as we're waiting for a
- 26:14clinical trial to become available.
- 26:16We are beginning to study and
- 26:18use these Kras drugs,
- 26:19and I think that's going
- 26:21to be the next paradigm.
- 26:22So we've gone from chemotherapy
- 26:24to targeted therapy,
- 26:24to immunotherapy, and now Kras
- 26:26which is another target.
- 26:27But it's a broad target
- 26:29and it always was
- 26:30the Holy Grail,
- 26:32there's been so many
- 26:34approaches and ways to try to target it.
- 26:36It's a very difficult target for
- 26:38a cancer because I don't want
- 26:40to get into too much detail here,
- 26:42but just to say that the pocket that
- 26:44we have to block with a drug is so
- 26:47narrow that it's very hard to get a
- 26:49drug in there to block that.
- 26:52But scientists and chemists have
- 26:53figured that out. Another example of
- 26:55science drives innovation,
- 26:56science brings new agents to the clinic.
- 26:58Then we test them in the clinic
- 27:00and we test them using samples
- 27:03from patients and a series of
- 27:05very careful studies to bring new
- 27:08new things to standard of care.
- 27:10So amazing progress but
- 27:12more that needs to
- 27:13happen. And this brings me
- 27:15to the whole area of clinical trials.
- 27:18For many patients historically
- 27:20they always thought that clinical trials
- 27:22were what you tried when there was nothing
- 27:25else left when you had exhausted all
- 27:28other options when the cancer was metastatic NOTE Confidence: 0.856393
- 27:31and had spread all over the body,
- 27:34but you're really talking about
- 27:36clinical trials as being
- 27:40state of the art medicine and
- 27:43that might actually be helpful,
- 27:45particularly in patients who are so
- 27:47fortunate as to have detected their
- 27:49cancer early when it's not metastatic.
- 27:52Can you talk a little bit more about that?
- 27:59Clinical trials really are
- 28:03the best way and in many cases
- 28:06to you know, treating cancer,
- 28:08especially when you're dealing with
- 28:11a situation where you know it is
- 28:14incurable and you're not able to
- 28:16treat with the standard of care,
- 28:18I still remember the example of the
- 28:21patient, has to be about 8 years ago,
- 28:23we were studying a drug in clinical trial,
- 28:26one of these immune checkpoint inhibitors
- 28:28and he came in with advanced lung cancer.
- 28:30He had already been to see several
- 28:33other practitioners around
- 28:35the state and we had one slot left
- 28:37in this trial and you know we went
- 28:39back and forth and he decided to
- 28:41go on this study and he went on
- 28:44this drug that is now approved and
- 28:46did very well.
- 28:47Eight years later,
- 28:48I still get emails from him.
- 28:50He's a photographer.
- 28:51He sends me pictures from the wild.
- 28:53This is where a clinical trial
- 28:55can really pay off now,
- 28:57because now many years before
- 28:58approval of a drug,
- 28:59someone took a chance on this trial
- 29:01that the alternative would have
- 29:03been standard of care therapy.
- 29:04So we're not keeping anything
- 29:06from this patient,
- 29:07but bring that trial to bear
- 29:09on that patient really helped him
- 29:11and helped him live a quality life.
- 29:13So that's what we hope for.
- 29:15That's why clinical trials are so important.
- 29:17And now I think, as you're alluding to,
- 29:19we're using these clinical trials
- 29:21in the earliest stages of disease,
- 29:22so I know you're a surgeon,
- 29:24so you cut out tumors,
- 29:26but still there's a chance it will recur
- 29:29even if you've gotten everything out.
- 29:30So now what we're doing is we're taking
- 29:33these best therapies in lung cancer,
- 29:36the immunotherapy that targeted therapy
- 29:38when using them after surgery even
- 29:40when we see that there's no disease.
- 29:41Knowing that these are high risk
- 29:43of recurrence and those data,
- 29:45some of them are already showing
- 29:48positive results so
- 29:49the field of research and clinical
- 29:51care are one and the bottom line
- 29:53is we want to give the best
- 29:55care for patients at the best
- 29:57possible time.
- 29:59Dr. Roy Herbst is Ensign Professor of Medicine in Medical Oncology
- 30:00and professor of Pharmacology
- 30:03at the Yale School of Medicine.
- 30:05If you have questions,
- 30:06the address is canceranswers@yale.edu
- 30:08and past editions of the program
- 30:10are available in audio and written
- 30:12form at yalecancercenter.org.
- 30:14We hope you'll join us next week to
- 30:16learn more about the fight against
- 30:19cancer here on Connecticut Public Radio.