Smilow Shares: Breast Cancer at Waterford/Westerly
October 29, 2020Information
Smilow Shares: Breast Cancer Awareness, presented by the Smilow Cancer Hospital Care Center in Waterford and Westerly
Mehra Golshan, MD, MBA - Professor of Surgery (Oncology) and Interim Director of the Breast Center at Smilow Cancer Hospital
Anca Bulgaru, MD - Assistant Professor of Medicine (Medical Oncology)
Robert Legare, MD - Associate Professor of Clinical Medicine (Medical Oncology) and Medical Director of the Smilow Cancer Hospital Care Centers in Waterford and Westerly
Meena Moran, MD - Professor of Therapeutic Radiology, Director of Breast Radiotherapy
ID5827
To CiteDCA Citation Guide
- 00:00Good evening everyone.
- 00:01My name is Mara, Gulshan Anama,
- 00:04breast cancer surgeon, here at Yale.
- 00:08The clinical director of the breast program,
- 00:10Ann, really excited to be here
- 00:13this evening for the Smilow shares
- 00:15breast Cancer Awareness Month.
- 00:18Where we have a three preeminent
- 00:20authorities and breast cancer,
- 00:22this evening doctor,
- 00:24Uncle Garo we're going to have Doctor
- 00:27Bob Legare and Doctor Mina Moran
- 00:29talk about advances in oncology,
- 00:32radiation therapy,
- 00:33and really just a state of the art and
- 00:36treatment in breast cancer were going
- 00:39to have three separate presentations.
- 00:42And then at the end there will be a
- 00:46question and answer period where.
- 00:49And even in advance of the end,
- 00:51if you want,
- 00:52please put in any questions into the
- 00:55chat box or on the Q and a box that
- 00:57sat at the bottom of your screen.
- 01:00We've held two of these forums
- 01:02for Yale for the New Haven and
- 01:04also for the Fairfield,
- 01:05Bridgeport,
- 01:06but it's been a really well received
- 01:08and this is going to be the
- 01:10highlight of the month for breast
- 01:12cancer awareness and Smilow shares.
- 01:14So with no further ado,
- 01:16we're going to start with Doctor
- 01:18Bob Legare who's going to talk.
- 01:20About some advances in breast
- 01:22medical oncology.
- 01:22Then Doctor Mina Maranan radiation
- 01:24and certainly not last and not
- 01:27least but will have Doctor Bogart
- 01:29talk a little bit more about some
- 01:32of the advances in oncology and
- 01:34then look forward to some really
- 01:36great questions from the audience.
- 01:38Thank you Doctor Laghari at
- 01:40the floor is yours.
- 01:42Thank you, I appreciate that and I'm
- 01:45very happy to be with everyone tonight.
- 01:48And I'm going to try to share my screen.
- 01:51Just let me know if you can see things.
- 01:55Properly, can you see my screen?
- 01:59OK, so good evening and very excited
- 02:02to share some thoughts with you.
- 02:05Um, you know regarding breast cancer,
- 02:07maybe where we're heading where we
- 02:09hope to head, and some of the advances
- 02:11that we've seen come forward this year.
- 02:14We know that breast cancer remains.
- 02:16Significant, it's the most common
- 02:18malignancy that's not a non
- 02:21Melanoma skin cancer in women,
- 02:23estimated to be about 276
- 02:25thousand new cases this year.
- 02:28So we know that this is a very significant.
- 02:33Issue for our women across the
- 02:35world and certainly United States
- 02:37and something where research,
- 02:39really, I think is moving forward
- 02:41in a very hopeful way you can see
- 02:44on that top sort of purple pink
- 02:46part of this graph that you know,
- 02:49breast cancer probably had a
- 02:50little bit of a dip in the early
- 02:532000s in terms of incidence rates,
- 02:55and that was perhaps based on
- 02:57folks moving a little bit away
- 02:59from home replacement therapy.
- 03:01And then after that we can
- 03:03see maybe a slow rise maybe.
- 03:05.3% per year increase in risk of
- 03:08breast cancer that we've seen.
- 03:10Subsequent to that,
- 03:12perhaps over the last decade.
- 03:14And I would say it, you know,
- 03:16as a combination of.
- 03:18Early detection with mammogram having
- 03:20shown to decrease mortality from
- 03:23breast cancer through screening.
- 03:25And also with advances in
- 03:27treatment we've seen.
- 03:29Thankfully,
- 03:29especially over the last decade,
- 03:31you know significant decrease
- 03:33in breast cancer mortality,
- 03:35so we've seen perhaps a 40% decrease
- 03:38in breast cancer mortality since 1989,
- 03:41after seeing essentially
- 03:42fairly flat lines before then,
- 03:44you can see that again in that
- 03:47purple pink curve there on the graph.
- 03:51So we are making progress.
- 03:53We can never be complacent.
- 03:56Now we have a long way to go,
- 03:58but there's this room for hope.
- 04:01When we look at 5 year survival rates,
- 04:04this can also be reflected going
- 04:07from the 70s to the 80s to you
- 04:10know the last decade and we're
- 04:12seeing five year survival rates
- 04:15increased from 75 to 84 to 91%.
- 04:20I was going to focus a bit on ER
- 04:22positive her two negative breast
- 04:24cancer and later tonight you'll hear
- 04:27some advances and her two positive
- 04:29breast cancer from Doctor Ogarro.
- 04:31We know that.
- 04:32Early breast cancer accounts for
- 04:35perhaps 90% of breast cancers
- 04:36diagnosed in women and 70% of those
- 04:39are hormone hormone receptor positive.
- 04:41In her two negative,
- 04:42we know that thankfully most women
- 04:44won't experience a recurrence,
- 04:46but some women will be at higher
- 04:48risk and those would be folks who
- 04:50have had high risk features and
- 04:52they can experience recurrence.
- 04:54Sometimes within the first few years
- 04:56and one of the questions that we ask,
- 04:59is you know why is this happening
- 05:02on our current therapeutics,
- 05:03and one question that we look at.
- 05:06Is is the question of.
- 05:09Endocrine refractory nessuno.
- 05:10When one is getting treated, say,
- 05:12with endocrine therapy of some type,
- 05:14what's permissive for that cell if
- 05:16it exists within the body to then
- 05:19grow back and manifest as stage four
- 05:21cancer after one is presented with
- 05:24early stage cancer, and there is some
- 05:26interesting trials that that we're
- 05:28looking at this question a bit at our
- 05:31American Society of clinical oncology
- 05:33meetings earlier this year, so it's
- 05:35hoping to highlight just a few of those.
- 05:39Trials and then to just take a look at some
- 05:42of the clinical research that's happening
- 05:44at Yale right now to share with you.
- 05:47This was a cartoon of sort of cell cycle
- 05:51kinetics if you will and how a protein calls.
- 05:56You know cyclin D works and how it affects
- 05:59cell cycle kinetics and just looking
- 06:02at that that that green circle RBRB,
- 06:06which is the retinoblastoma gene,
- 06:08is very important in controlling
- 06:10whether a cell replicates,
- 06:12you know, makes a copy of itself.
- 06:16Cell Grove cell replication.
- 06:18We know that dysregulated cell growth and
- 06:21replication is the hallmark of cancer.
- 06:24Now we know that mutations within cancer
- 06:27cells are what ultimately causes that
- 06:30this data in the stage 4 setting that
- 06:34adding a cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor
- 06:37to endocrine therapy hormone therapy,
- 06:40like anastrozole or an aromat
- 06:43ACE inhibitor or a surd like.
- 06:46A full best friend can almost double
- 06:49the progression free survival in the
- 06:51stage for setting, and like many,
- 06:54many aspects of how we study cancer.
- 06:56If something looks very hopeful
- 06:58in the stage for setting,
- 07:00we try to move it back to the early brand.
- 07:05Cancer setting and say hey,
- 07:07can we do better so documenting
- 07:09benefit in the advanced setting?
- 07:12In trying to block that.
- 07:15Movement from the G1 phase
- 07:18of the cell cycle to the.
- 07:23DNA replication phase.
- 07:26We've tried to look at these agents
- 07:29in the early stage of breast cancer,
- 07:32so this is a trial called Monarch that
- 07:35looked at a women who had early stage
- 07:38breast cancer that had some high risk
- 07:41features such as four or more involved
- 07:44lymph nodes or one to three involve
- 07:46lymph nodes with other high risk
- 07:49features like grade or size of the tumor,
- 07:52large tumors,
- 07:53and it was a big trial with over 5000 women.
- 07:57And essentially randomize those
- 07:58women to endocrine therapy.
- 08:00On the left you can see ET with a
- 08:03particular cyclin dependent kinase
- 08:05inhibitor called abemaciclib,
- 08:07or endocrine therapy alone.
- 08:08So half the group got integrant therapy,
- 08:11half the group got ended.
- 08:13Contrary with this cyclin
- 08:15dependent kinase inhibitor,
- 08:16and this was a phase three randomized
- 08:19trial in what you can see where
- 08:22I put those numbers of 88.7 and
- 08:2592.2% is we're seeing with a median
- 08:28follow up about 15.5 months.
- 08:30But the curves there are
- 08:32starting to separate,
- 08:33and we're seeing that the folks who received
- 08:35the cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor,
- 08:37some of them,
- 08:38seem to be doing better.
- 08:40The absolute benefit was perhaps 3.3 or 3.4%,
- 08:43but it's early in this trial,
- 08:45and this is a signal to us that we
- 08:47might be seeing an important benefit
- 08:50for some women by adding this agent in.
- 08:53So I think that right now this
- 08:55could be an
- 08:56option for some women with
- 08:58very high risk features.
- 08:59I'd like to see confirmatory
- 09:01trial saying that.
- 09:02This another cyclin dependent
- 09:03kinase inhibitors.
- 09:04There are three that are FDA approved,
- 09:06but the other two shows similar benefit,
- 09:09but I was really happy to see this
- 09:11presented and this was actually a
- 09:13different meeting called an ECMO
- 09:15meeting in earlier this year,
- 09:17which is a sort of a parallel
- 09:20to our American meeting.
- 09:22I want to focus just a minute on
- 09:25another targeted therapy that's
- 09:26had FDA approval for a few years
- 09:29in the setting of stage four.
- 09:31Again, ER positive her two
- 09:33negative breast cancer.
- 09:34When this is an agent called El Pela
- 09:38Sib and this we can see here is.
- 09:41Did this agent specifically blocks
- 09:44the Alpha isoform of a protein.
- 09:47There you can see in pink called
- 09:50π three kinase.
- 09:52And if you look at this cartoon on
- 09:54the out in the outside world where
- 09:56that orange Circle says growth factor,
- 09:58these are the proteins that are still.
- 10:00Emulating cells to grow to divide
- 10:02to make more of themselves.
- 10:05And can we get at that particular cells?
- 10:08Cell mechanics?
- 10:08Can we get that in block it to try
- 10:12to prevent these cells from either
- 10:14moving through endocrine therapy?
- 10:16Or can we make integrant therapy,
- 10:19you know,
- 10:19work better and so that's kind
- 10:22of what we're looking at here.
- 10:24What we've seen is that in the Stage 4
- 10:28setting for a particular subtype of women.
- 10:31These agents can be very effective and
- 10:33that was a trial called Solar One,
- 10:36and in that trial again almost a
- 10:39doubling of disease free survival for women,
- 10:41you know with the you know with this
- 10:45agent and what we've seen is that.
- 10:48You know about 40% of women with
- 10:51PR positive her two negative
- 10:53advanced breast cancer Harbor
- 10:55this mutation so L pelis.
- 10:57It really is in a way a
- 11:01targeted therapy getting at a.
- 11:04A regulation problem where the
- 11:06cells are sort of hyper stimulated.
- 11:08They have a mutation in this gene.
- 11:10This mutation is permissive for
- 11:12cell growth and cell division
- 11:14and so adding it you know and
- 11:16it's not an uncommon mutation,
- 11:18it's in 40% of folks with PR
- 11:21positive her negative breast cancer.
- 11:23So hope rugo at UCSF had said well
- 11:25and we look specifically at this
- 11:27subgroup that has you know this
- 11:29mutation in already has seen that
- 11:31cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor that
- 11:34we talked about a while ago because.
- 11:36As our newer therapies coming to play,
- 11:39we're trying to understand the
- 11:40influence of a prior treatment
- 11:42on a subsequent treatment.
- 11:44So the question the Doctor
- 11:45Rugo is asking was well,
- 11:47since cyclin dependent kinase
- 11:49inhibitors that we looked at earlier
- 11:51since that standard of care for
- 11:53women with advanced ER positive
- 11:55her two negative breast cancer.
- 11:57What about women who have
- 11:59been exposed to that?
- 12:00Will they still respond to this new agent?
- 12:03Help Ellis,
- 12:04if in the context of this
- 12:05π three kinase mutation,
- 12:07if they had been exposed to
- 12:09the cyclin dependent kinase
- 12:11inhibitor and I was very happy to see that
- 12:13the grass here look very similar between her,
- 12:16the original solar one trial that
- 12:18was published a few years ago,
- 12:21and this trial called by Leave,
- 12:23where if you can look at the graph with
- 12:26the sort of vertical lines going down?
- 12:29That would suggest a response in
- 12:31terms of decreasing size of tumor in
- 12:33the grass almost mimic each other,
- 12:35so they're sort of saying that, well,
- 12:38we do believe that this agent is going
- 12:40to be effective in women who have had
- 12:43a cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor,
- 12:45and so you know someone coming
- 12:47through with standard therapy,
- 12:49ER positive disease,
- 12:50stage four disease,
- 12:51getting endocrine therapy,
- 12:52and a cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor.
- 12:54If they have this π three kinase mutation,
- 12:57this is a very viable.
- 12:59Option for them to go forward and
- 13:01again a doubling of the disease.
- 13:03Free survival rate so you know
- 13:05moving forward trying to get beyond
- 13:07endocrine refractory disease.
- 13:08So to me that was very hopeful.
- 13:12So I wanted to transition for a minute
- 13:14and just spend a few minutes looking
- 13:16at some clinical trials we have up
- 13:18and running at Yale and some of the
- 13:21focus that were that we're looking at.
- 13:23And you know,
- 13:24part of what we understand with cancer is.
- 13:28You know lifestyle exposures and one
- 13:30of the questions that were trying
- 13:33to look at is exemplified in this.
- 13:35Be well trial.
- 13:36The PR here is Doctor Sands and
- 13:39this is a trial looking at saying
- 13:41you know is weight loss after
- 13:44being diagnosed with breast cancer.
- 13:46You know can that affect outcome?
- 13:48So this is a very large trial across the
- 13:51country in women are being randomized
- 13:54to either you know no intervention or
- 13:56an intervention with counseling about diet.
- 13:59And weight loss and seeing if that translates
- 14:02into an outcome of benefit for these women.
- 14:04So this is an important important study.
- 14:06We know that women coming
- 14:08in with breast cancer,
- 14:09if they are considered,
- 14:10you know clinically overweight.
- 14:11You know,
- 14:12sometimes their outcome that some
- 14:14data supporting the fact of their
- 14:16outcome might not be as good
- 14:17as women who are a bit leaner,
- 14:19so we're trying to understand that better.
- 14:22This is a trial called the ABC trial,
- 14:25and looking at aspirin in early stage
- 14:28breast cancer and the question being
- 14:31asked here in Doctor Fishback as the
- 14:34Pi of this trial we we really have a
- 14:36deep resource of multiple oncologists.
- 14:38We're focusing on breast cancer.
- 14:40Yale and I think that really delivers.
- 14:44Innovation and quality care to our patients.
- 14:47Know aspirin and other agents like
- 14:49aspirin had been looked at in multiple
- 14:52malignancies for potentially, you know,
- 14:54preventing or decreasing risk,
- 14:56and this is a trial asking the question.
- 14:59Well,
- 15:00there's a lot of basis to consider this
- 15:03question as very relevant question.
- 15:05Could the addition of aspirin affect outcome?
- 15:08Would women potentially do better?
- 15:10So this is a very real relevant
- 15:13trial for us
- 15:14as well. I just left a few other trials.
- 15:18Alot of these happen to be national trials,
- 15:21but just to look at the top three,
- 15:24one looking at different molecular changes
- 15:26in a womans breast tumor and then randomize
- 15:30a different therapy before surgery.
- 15:32Based on what those with
- 15:33the molecular profile,
- 15:35the molecular landscape might look at again,
- 15:37doctors, Santas, the Pi for that trial.
- 15:41Another trial you know,
- 15:42perhaps like that Monarch trial?
- 15:44Looking at cyclin dependent kinase
- 15:46inhibitors in early breast cancer trial
- 15:48called Natalie using an alternative cyclin
- 15:50dependent kinase inhibitor riverstick Lib,
- 15:52and asking the similar question
- 15:54folks with high risk disease,
- 15:56would they do better with the addition
- 15:59of this agent in another trial?
- 16:01Looking at more advanced disease and Doctor,
- 16:04Mongolian is the P for that
- 16:06trial and that trial.
- 16:08Asking the question,
- 16:09you know we follow folks with advanced
- 16:11disease stage four disease with serial scans.
- 16:14How are we doing?
- 16:16Is the patient responding to
- 16:18treatment tumor markers guide us?
- 16:20Can they influence when we order CAT scans?
- 16:23Can we do less image Ng exposed women to
- 16:26less radiation and get similar outcomes?
- 16:29So a lot of a lot of interesting
- 16:31trials from different perspectives.
- 16:34And just to mention that more and
- 16:36more in the advanced cancer setting,
- 16:39we're looking to understand the
- 16:41molecular landscape, so we want to.
- 16:43Study the the genetics of the tumor
- 16:46by a biopsy and then sometimes
- 16:48by what we call a liquid biopsy.
- 16:51Getting a blood sample and looking
- 16:53for circulating tumor DNA.
- 16:55And we're doing that more and more
- 16:57to try to tailor our treatment
- 17:00to the most effective therapies.
- 17:02And this is becoming commonplace for us.
- 17:05And this is a trial that one of
- 17:08our lead researchers Doctor Push
- 17:10Die is going to be the Pi of.
- 17:13And this is a trial in early stage
- 17:16disease and asking the question.
- 17:18Well if we follow women on endocrine
- 17:20therapy after they've had their
- 17:22surgery and we've had other
- 17:24treatment in the agement setting.
- 17:26So after surgery,
- 17:27as you know when when someone say on,
- 17:30you know in Aromat ACE inhibitor.
- 17:35If we check their blood intermittently
- 17:38looking for circulating tumor DNA,
- 17:41if we see a certain signal as defined
- 17:44by the investigators and we acted
- 17:47on that signal to change treatment,
- 17:51say from typical adjeman
- 17:52endocrine therapy to adding, say,
- 17:55an agent like fulvestrant into
- 17:57cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor.
- 17:59For instance, do these folks do better?
- 18:03So again, trying to get it back question of
- 18:06if we come in early with different treatment,
- 18:09adding a second agent you know will our folks
- 18:11do better in terms of disease recurrence.
- 18:14I'm very eager to see this trial
- 18:16begin as well and I wanted to briefly
- 18:19touch on you know what might be new in
- 18:22genetics and how this could affect you.
- 18:24Know some of our patients in the
- 18:27clinic and some folks who have certain
- 18:29hereditary risk so we know that.
- 18:32Our folks have inherited ABRC A1 or BRC A2.
- 18:36Mutation has some special issues with
- 18:38tumor DNA repair and we call that
- 18:41homologous recombination deficiency.
- 18:43We know that some of these cancers are
- 18:46more challenging in terms of double
- 18:49stranded DNA repair because we know
- 18:52that cells are always having trouble,
- 18:54and if they can't,
- 18:56you know if they can't repair themselves,
- 18:59they would have a signal too.
- 19:02Parrish,
- 19:02and so we want to try to take
- 19:05advantage of maybe an inherent
- 19:07weakness within the BRC A1 cell.
- 19:09In this class of drugs
- 19:10called PARP inhibitors,
- 19:11I put two in here elaborate
- 19:14and tell is Zopa rib,
- 19:15which are FDA approved for advanced
- 19:18cancer that have been looked at in trials
- 19:20in the stage for setting for women
- 19:23with BRC A1 and B RCA two mutations
- 19:25and their effective and their helpful.
- 19:27And they're part of our standard treatment
- 19:30regiment for folks who have burst.
- 19:32My 2 mutations and one of the questions
- 19:35that Nadine Tung asked at ASCO this year was,
- 19:38well,
- 19:39you know,
- 19:39what about folks who might have
- 19:42other hereditary mutations beyond
- 19:43BRC A1 and B RCA 2?
- 19:45Because we're finding there are
- 19:47other high penetrance genes that can
- 19:50increase the risk for breast cancer
- 19:52with these people benefit from.
- 19:54The addition of a PARP inhibitor.
- 19:57And what about folks who have
- 19:59acquired mutate?
- 20:00Susan BRC A1 and BRC,
- 20:02two so these are folks who don't
- 20:04have hereditary breast cancer,
- 20:06but there are tumor cells have acquired
- 20:08mutations in those same genes.
- 20:10OK,
- 20:10and so the question is almost
- 20:12like Achilles heel question.
- 20:14Well, if the cell has a problem with repair.
- 20:17With one mechanism,
- 20:18because we know our cells are smart,
- 20:21so they've created multiple.
- 20:22You know,
- 20:23evolution is created multiple ways
- 20:25for cells to repair themselves.
- 20:27If we take out the single strand DNA
- 20:29repair mechanism with PARP inhibitors,
- 20:31could that lead to cancer cells perishing?
- 20:34We call that concept synthetic
- 20:36lethality and so this was a trial
- 20:38where folks with other mutations
- 20:40and I just want to highlight what
- 20:42we thought were the seminal aspects
- 20:45of this trial.
- 20:46There's a gene called Pal B2,
- 20:48partner and localized, or V RCA two,
- 20:50and it's a gene that also, when inherited,
- 20:53can increase the risk for breast cancer,
- 20:56and so in the hereditary setting.
- 20:58It was significant response with
- 21:00PARP inhibitors to the folks
- 21:02who had the PAL V2 mutation.
- 21:04So to me that that's getting
- 21:06very close to saying well,
- 21:08folks who have breast cancer in the
- 21:10context of this mutation like BRC A1B,
- 21:13RCA two are candidates for a PARP inhibitor
- 21:15was also very interesting in the middle.
- 21:18Here is it folks would acquire what we
- 21:21call a semantic BRC A1-AB or C2 mutation.
- 21:24They too seem to have an excellent
- 21:26response rate to these agents
- 21:28in the advanced cancer setting.
- 21:30So this was interesting and I think
- 21:32it's going to be relevant for us and
- 21:35just to mention that's in contrast
- 21:37to folks with an ATM or check two
- 21:40mutation to other genes that can be
- 21:42associated with hereditary breast cancer.
- 21:44Those folks didn't seem to benefit, OK?
- 21:46So I found that very interesting
- 21:48and one of our investigators,
- 21:51Doctor Larosa at Yale,
- 21:52has a trial at trying to mention this
- 21:55trucks and it's very relevant for our
- 21:57folks with germline mutations in V RC1BR,
- 22:00C two and you'll hear more about
- 22:03checkpoint inhibitors from doctoral Garo.
- 22:05But this is a trial saying well if we have
- 22:08folks who have benefit from a PARP inhibitor.
- 22:11If we add a checkpoint inhibitor might
- 22:13they do better 'cause there's some
- 22:16very interesting science behind that.
- 22:18Suggesting that those medicines could
- 22:20work very well together in our patients.
- 22:23So for me it was a Goodyear,
- 22:26a hopeful year looking at ways
- 22:28to overcome enterkin resistance.
- 22:30Some improvements as relates to how
- 22:32we understand hereditary cancer
- 22:34in the treatment thereof.
- 22:35And this is just a slide from the
- 22:38summer of some women that I know
- 22:41in Westerly who are doing yoga at
- 22:44sunrise on the beach and for me
- 22:47it's sort of symbolized hope.
- 22:49I do have great hope for this.
- 22:51I wanted to share that with you.
- 22:53Thank you.
- 22:55That was fantastic.
- 22:56Loved love that last slide
- 22:58and obviously all the data and
- 23:01the trials that are underway,
- 23:02especially here at Yale and Smilow.
- 23:05Next, we're going to move to
- 23:07Doctor Mina Moran and discuss the
- 23:09advances in radiation therapy
- 23:10and some of the really exciting
- 23:13techniques that are out there now.
- 23:28You're on mute.
- 23:34Is still on on mute.
- 23:39But while those slides are coming,
- 23:41there was a question about 100.
- 23:43It was from Pam regarding 100%
- 23:45breast tissue density and how
- 23:47confident you could be an image Ng.
- 23:50I think that's a fantastic question.
- 23:52We're going to absolutely get that
- 23:54in our question and answer session.
- 23:57And also, what are the signs
- 23:59and symptoms of breast cancer?
- 24:01And I think really super relevant questions.
- 24:03So with no further ado,
- 24:05Doctor Moran, professor and director,
- 24:07radiation Oncology at Yale.
- 24:09Thank you, I apologize for that.
- 24:11I'm having some technical difficulties today,
- 24:13so I'm going to be talking to you about
- 24:17radiation and just to give you an idea,
- 24:19you know one of the things I want to
- 24:22talk about is just the general principles
- 24:25of practices for breast radiation,
- 24:26such as the role of radiation
- 24:28in breast conservation therapy,
- 24:30the role of radiation after mastectomy,
- 24:32and the use of radiation
- 24:33in the palliative setting.
- 24:35I want to talk about radiation,
- 24:37what it is makes a lot of patients that
- 24:39come for consultation don't really have an.
- 24:42Idea of what it is or what it does.
- 24:45And Lastly,
- 24:46I want to talk about some of the
- 24:48technological advances that we now are
- 24:50using routinely in our practices to
- 24:53decrease normal tissue.
- 24:56So when a patient is newly diagnosed
- 24:59with early stage breast cancer,
- 25:01one of the major decisions that they face is
- 25:05the choice between Ms Ectomy or lumpectomy.
- 25:08If they are a candidate for a lumpectomy.
- 25:11And this shows long-term survival,
- 25:14following a lumpectomy with
- 25:15radiation versus the mastectomy.
- 25:17And as you can see here,
- 25:20that the outcomes in terms of
- 25:22long-term survival are equivalent.
- 25:24And this is nevertheless a persistent myth.
- 25:27But Patience feels that once the
- 25:29breast is a fully removed that
- 25:32their outcomes may be better,
- 25:34but unfortunately that isn't it.
- 25:36Fortunately, or unfortunately,
- 25:37they're not.
- 25:38It is not the case,
- 25:40and what we see is that more and
- 25:43more women over the last decade or
- 25:46so have been choosing mastectomy
- 25:48over a breast conservation.
- 25:50Ultimately that the outcomes are the same,
- 25:53and So what are the indications
- 25:55for when a patient may require?
- 25:58Radiation,
- 25:58the most common indication is in the
- 26:01use of breast conservation therapy,
- 26:03which is defined as limited surgery to
- 26:06remove the tumor with negative margins,
- 26:09and that's followed by whole breast
- 26:12radiation with an assessment of the
- 26:14lymph nodes and breast conservation therapy.
- 26:17As I said,
- 26:18is a standard alternative to mastectomy
- 26:20for early stage breast cancer and
- 26:23provides equivalent long-term outcomes
- 26:25up to 25 years for eligible patients.
- 26:28So after.
- 26:29Lumpectomy the alternatives
- 26:30to whole breast radiation,
- 26:32can also be a partial breast
- 26:34radiation therapy plan,
- 26:36where the lumpectomy cavity is outlined.
- 26:39And we're treating just that
- 26:41small portion of the breast.
- 26:43This approach is actually quite promising.
- 26:47Appears to have good cosmesis,
- 26:49but the studies are newer than the
- 26:52traditional whole breast radiation
- 26:54and they have significantly shorter
- 26:55follow-up and so currently it's only
- 26:58being offered for selected low risk patients.
- 27:00And then Lastly,
- 27:02there's one group of patients where
- 27:04we routinely offer them radiation,
- 27:07omission,
- 27:07or just having the lumpectomy with
- 27:09a no additional aggregate radiation.
- 27:11And this is for patients over the
- 27:14age of approximately 65 to 70 who
- 27:17haviar positive tumors that measure
- 27:18less than two to three centimeters,
- 27:21and who have negative nodes,
- 27:23and who are willing to commit
- 27:25to tamoxifen for five years.
- 27:27And what we
- 27:28tell these patients is that they
- 27:30their risk of. The cancer coming
- 27:32back within the breast is higher,
- 27:34but if it does come back they can
- 27:36ultimately have a mastectomy and so
- 27:38therefore there is no survival difference.
- 27:43What are the indications for a after
- 27:46a mastectomy to do radiation well,
- 27:49radiation is typically offered in the post
- 27:52mastectomy setting for high risk patients,
- 27:55and it's used to sterilize microscopic
- 27:58disease on the chest wall.
- 28:00In regional lymph nodes.
- 28:03Typically the radiation is a delivered entire
- 28:06chest wall and any lymph nodes at risk.
- 28:09The patients that we consider
- 28:11for most mastectomy radiation are
- 28:14those who have positive nodes.
- 28:16Those who have positive margins if
- 28:18they have tumor that involves the skin,
- 28:21or if they have a tumor that
- 28:23measures of five centimeters.
- 28:28So whether it's.
- 28:31Text me or post mastectomy radiation.
- 28:34It's important to recognize that
- 28:36radiation is very safe and effective
- 28:38and is much better tolerated than it
- 28:42was years ago due to the advances that
- 28:45we've made and radiation generally
- 28:47reduces local and regional recurrences
- 28:49by approximately 60 to 70%, which is a
- 28:53relative risk reduction of about 2/3.
- 28:57In certain subsets of patients,
- 28:58radiation is also associated with an increase
- 29:00in survival and could be as high as 10%,
- 29:03and this is particularly true
- 29:05of the younger patients who have
- 29:07a very long life expectancy.
- 29:10The treatment is almost always given
- 29:12after chemotherapy and the treatment
- 29:15duration of radiation is specific to
- 29:17the patient and it can be as good as six
- 29:20weeks out from from beginning to end.
- 29:24So the last major an indication for radiation
- 29:27is for patients in the metastatic setting
- 29:30or in the recurrent disease setting.
- 29:33Or a patient has disease
- 29:35that's causing symptoms.
- 29:36In these situations the radiation is that
- 29:38delivered is given in a pallet of way,
- 29:41meaning that it's used to alleviate
- 29:44the symptoms that the patient
- 29:45might be experiencing,
- 29:47and it's highly effective.
- 29:48It can be up to 70 to 90% of
- 29:52patients do resport report that
- 29:54they have a very good pain control.
- 29:57But the fractionation in
- 29:58differs significantly.
- 29:59Can be anyway?
- 30:00From 10 to 15 treatments or as
- 30:03little as one to two treatments,
- 30:05depending on the site and the
- 30:07performance status of the patients,
- 30:09and typically it's used for things
- 30:11like bone lesions, brain metastasis,
- 30:13soft tissue masses or even chest
- 30:16wall recurrences.
- 30:17So just an important point.
- 30:19Lastly,
- 30:19for all treatment of breast cancer,
- 30:21I think it's important to remember
- 30:23that every breast cancer is different,
- 30:25and so the biology is different in every
- 30:28case as well as patient related factors
- 30:30that that a physician has to consider.
- 30:32In addition,
- 30:33we have to look at the efficacy of
- 30:36the treatment as well as the toxicity
- 30:38and then look at the risks versus the
- 30:41benefits to make sure that it's it's
- 30:43worth the treatments for the patient.
- 30:45So in addition to the doctors.
- 30:47Recommendation for their whether
- 30:49or not to deliver radiation and
- 30:51other important components that
- 30:53sometimes gets neglected but should
- 30:56be discussed is the patients of
- 30:59personal preferences and what they
- 31:01want to do and how they would receive.
- 31:04So now what is radiation?
- 31:06Radiation is a high energy X Ray beam,
- 31:10not very different than a chest
- 31:12X Ray or cat scan.
- 31:14They all use ionizing radiation,
- 31:16but the magnitude of the energy
- 31:19is significantly greater,
- 31:20up for therapeutic radiation and
- 31:22ultimately what it does is it causes
- 31:25damage to any of the cells that are
- 31:28in the radiations pathway and so
- 31:31within our field of radiation oncology.
- 31:34Our goal is to try to use.
- 31:37The radiation to minimize the
- 31:39chance of the cancer coming back
- 31:41locally or regionally.
- 31:42And we do this by trying to individualize
- 31:45the beams to the patients anatomy
- 31:47and target the areas at risk for
- 31:50recurrence and minimize the dose to
- 31:52the normal tissue wherever possible.
- 31:56So how does radiation work while the
- 31:59individual X Ray beams target the
- 32:01DNA and normal cells as well through
- 32:04a direct and indirect mechanism?
- 32:06That's a little bit too difficult
- 32:09to explain in this short session,
- 32:12but ultimately what happens is that
- 32:14the the radiation causes damage
- 32:16to the DNA of any cell,
- 32:19and by doing this it ultimately
- 32:22prevents the cells from replicating
- 32:24unless they can repair themselves.
- 32:27And So what are the what are
- 32:30the exact types of damages?
- 32:32All different kinds but but the the
- 32:35damages are typically such that the
- 32:38cancer cells are not able to recover from it,
- 32:42whereas normal cells such as
- 32:44our skin lung tissue,
- 32:45our breast tissue is able
- 32:47to recover and for this
- 32:50reason it leads to cancer cell
- 32:52death when the cells try to
- 32:55reproduce or replicate, whereas.
- 32:57The normal tissue has the ability
- 33:00to repair and seal off and then
- 33:03continue with its normal life cycle.
- 33:07So when a patient comes in for radiation,
- 33:10sometimes they think that
- 33:11they're going to start radiation.
- 33:13The date if they have the consultation,
- 33:15and this is just to show you that there's
- 33:18actually a process that we follow.
- 33:19The patient first needs to undergo a see
- 33:22T simulation an it's a multi step process
- 33:24where we put the patient on the table.
- 33:27We immobilize them to make sure that we can
- 33:30reproduce their positioning on a daily basis.
- 33:32For the treatments we add some
- 33:34markers to their skin on their
- 33:36skin and then we get the scan.
- 33:38This is what one of the
- 33:40immobilization looks like.
- 33:42It is a vac lock with a breast board.
- 33:45Patients are required to put their
- 33:47arms up and so for this reason another
- 33:49important important point is that
- 33:51when patients come to radiation,
- 33:53they should be able to raise their
- 33:56arms comfortably and keep them up
- 33:58for at least 20 to 30 minutes in
- 34:01order for the CAT scan and the
- 34:04entire simulation process to occur.
- 34:07And so this is what the radiation
- 34:09feels look like.
- 34:10And this is just a schematic.
- 34:13But basically what happens is the
- 34:15head of the machine moves to the to
- 34:18one side of the breast or the chest
- 34:20wall tissue and it treats it and
- 34:23then moves to the other side and
- 34:25treats the other side of the breast.
- 34:28And by doing this we're really
- 34:30skimming the chest wall and not
- 34:32penetrating from the front to the
- 34:34back an in this way we're really just
- 34:37treating the superficial a tissue.
- 34:39Which includes the breast tissue.
- 34:42Here are the wires that we put on to
- 34:45clinically delineate what we want
- 34:47to make sure that we're covering
- 34:50an right underneath you see the two
- 34:53CT scans and in the pink you have
- 34:56the breast volume.
- 34:57The yellow that you see there is
- 35:00the lumpectomy volume and on the
- 35:03scan to the left side of the screen
- 35:05you see the three little areas that
- 35:09are outlined are your lymph nodes.
- 35:11In the axilla and the red line that I drew,
- 35:15is that tangential beam?
- 35:16So just to show you that we were
- 35:19able to cover a good portion of the
- 35:22breast and the level one Level 2
- 35:24and Level 3 lymph nodes with just
- 35:27a tangential beam alone?
- 35:29So ultimately this 3 dimensional
- 35:31technology with the use of CAT scans
- 35:34and looking at it at every different level,
- 35:37it allows us to contour the beam
- 35:39to an individual patients anatomy
- 35:41and it allows us to deliver precise
- 35:44and focused radiation beams.
- 35:46So what does radiation target
- 35:48and what do we try to target?
- 35:51Most patients who undergo breast
- 35:53conservation have their whole
- 35:54breast treated at this time.
- 35:56We may or may not include nodes
- 35:59if the patient.
- 36:00If it's indicated for the patient,
- 36:02for example, if they have positive nodes,
- 36:05we often will include the regional nodes.
- 36:07After the mastectomy,
- 36:08we treat the chest wall and
- 36:10a more often than not,
- 36:12because these are higher risk patients,
- 36:14they will have their regional nodes treated.
- 36:17And this is what the fields
- 36:19look like on the skin.
- 36:21So this is just a schematic to show you what
- 36:25the delivery of the tangential beams are.
- 36:28First, there's the medial beam or
- 36:30the medial part of the treatment,
- 36:33so you have the beam and sub beams within it,
- 36:37which are tailored to the
- 36:39individual patient and delete.
- 36:40Deliver the radiation medially.
- 36:42Then the beam moves into
- 36:44the lateral position,
- 36:45so the height of the machine
- 36:48moves to the lateral side of the
- 36:51patient and again similar beam.
- 36:53Delivers the tangential field and sub
- 36:55beams as well and ultimately together.
- 36:57What that gives you is a dose distribution
- 37:00that looks like what that purple
- 37:02and the yellow there are covering.
- 37:05So you're covering a good part of almost
- 37:08all of that breast tissue with a very
- 37:11little amount of lung or heart in the field.
- 37:15And so the goal is,
- 37:17as we're doing this treatment,
- 37:18planning is to design the beams in such a way
- 37:21that we treat the breast and the chest wall,
- 37:24with or without the lymph nodes,
- 37:26and we minimize the radiation
- 37:28to the normal tissue.
- 37:29And so we have a lot of tools
- 37:32that we are able to use,
- 37:34such as.
- 37:34Once we get the CAT scan,
- 37:36we can three dimensionally recreate
- 37:38the skin surface as well as the
- 37:40three dimensional internal surface
- 37:42so that we are able to see exactly
- 37:44where these beams intersect.
- 37:45And also then be able to change the
- 37:48beam a little bit in order to make sure
- 37:52that we're covering what we need to cover.
- 37:54The things that we worry about,
- 37:56the most critical things that we worry about
- 37:59are the the heart in the lung obviously,
- 38:02and sometimes the liver.
- 38:03And so we have two important tools
- 38:06that we use regularly to minimize
- 38:08that dose to the heart and lung.
- 38:10The first one is the deep inspiration,
- 38:12breath hold technique and the
- 38:14other one is the prone breast board
- 38:16technique and I'm just going to
- 38:18briefly talk about both of those.
- 38:20The deep inspiration breath
- 38:22hold technique allows a patient
- 38:24when they take a deep breath.
- 38:25Their chest wall moves away from
- 38:28the heart and and in doing so and
- 38:31with the diaphragm going down,
- 38:32what you have is more room for that
- 38:36tangential beam to get in there
- 38:38and to be able to treat without
- 38:40exposing the hearts and also it
- 38:42reduces the amount of a lung volume.
- 38:45So this is just an example to
- 38:48show you in a patient.
- 38:50On the left is the free breathing scan.
- 38:53On the right is the breath hold.
- 38:56In in red you see the heart contour,
- 38:59how much the heart shape changes in
- 39:02this particular patient when she
- 39:04holds her breath and that really
- 39:06allows us to get into the chest wall,
- 39:08the breast tissue and nodes,
- 39:10and miss the heart.
- 39:13This is just a cross section of
- 39:16that showing you
- 39:17again the decreased heart dose on the
- 39:19left you have the free breathing on the
- 39:22right you have the breath hold and how
- 39:25significant that change in anatomy is.
- 39:27Using this breath whole technique.
- 39:29So then the question is well, OK,
- 39:31fine, you do that on the CAT scan
- 39:34at the time of CT simulation.
- 39:37But what do you do day today for
- 39:39the six weeks of treatment that
- 39:41you're bringing the patient?
- 39:43In every day, well,
- 39:45we have very sophisticated lasers
- 39:47within the treatment room that
- 39:49project onto the patients skin and
- 39:52determine the exact position that
- 39:54the body contour should be in when
- 39:58the patient takes that deep breath.
- 40:01And these reference points are locked
- 40:03into our record and verify treatment system,
- 40:06and so the machine only turns on and
- 40:08delivers the radiation when the patient
- 40:11is in that exact precise breath hold,
- 40:14and this is within 3 millimeters,
- 40:16so anything more than 3 millimeters,
- 40:18the machine will not turn on and the patient
- 40:22holds their breath as long as they can,
- 40:25the machine delivers.
- 40:26It does what it's supposed to do as soon
- 40:30as the patient releases their breath.
- 40:32The machine turns off and then the
- 40:34patient catches up on their breath
- 40:36and you repeat the cycle until
- 40:38the entire treatment is delivered.
- 40:40So this is just a data showing you
- 40:43just one study looking at the IBH in in
- 40:46patients who have who do free breathing.
- 40:49These are just some cardiac parameters.
- 40:52You see that only about 50 to 60% with
- 40:55free breathing can avoid the cardiac
- 40:57structures to what is considered acceptable.
- 41:00With deep inspiration breath hold
- 41:02technique that increases to about 97%.
- 41:04So that's it's it's remarkable that it works
- 41:08very well in the vast majority of patients.
- 41:12But what about that last 3% of patients
- 41:15where the DB H doesn't work well?
- 41:17We have another technique.
- 41:19It's not as precise,
- 41:20but it does work very well.
- 41:22It's the prone board and what
- 41:24we do is we instead of having a
- 41:27patient patient on the left there
- 41:29with their laying on their back,
- 41:31you can see that their heart
- 41:33is clearly in the field,
- 41:35will put them in the prone position and we
- 41:38use gravity to have that breast fall forward,
- 41:41and it allows us.
- 41:43To treat the vast majority of the
- 41:45breast tissue in the chest wall
- 41:47without having to treat the heart,
- 41:50and so this is our alternative
- 41:52method for decreasing heart dose,
- 41:54and it works quite well as well.
- 41:56This is what the breast board looks like.
- 41:59Again,
- 42:00the ipsilateral breast or the side
- 42:02that we're treating hangs down the.
- 42:05Your side is pushed up and out of the way.
- 42:08We do similarly outline the volume of the
- 42:11breast tissue and the lumpectomy cavity.
- 42:13And an important point is that if a
- 42:16patient has a tumor that was originally
- 42:18very close to the chest wall,
- 42:21that would be a patient.
- 42:22For example,
- 42:23that we would not want to do breath holds.
- 42:26I mean not do prone breast board on
- 42:29because you are skimping a little
- 42:31bit on the very very posterior
- 42:33aspect of the chest wall there.
- 42:35But in the vast majority of
- 42:38patients that we do it in it,
- 42:40as long as their appropriately selected,
- 42:42it's a very effective technique as well.
- 42:45So in summary, radiation is an
- 42:47essential component to the multi
- 42:49disciplinary approach of breast cancer,
- 42:51and as I mentioned to you for
- 42:53early stage breast cancer,
- 42:55breast conservation therapy
- 42:56is equal to mastectomy,
- 42:58meaning that there is no difference
- 43:00in survival rates and for this reason
- 43:03I like to stress that mastectomy
- 43:05shouldn't be chosen by patients.
- 43:07Under the false pretense that
- 43:08they're going to have better outcomes
- 43:11by removing the whole breast,
- 43:13because this isn't the case.
- 43:15Also, don't choose mastectomy just
- 43:17to avoid radiation because you don't
- 43:19want to go through five weeks or
- 43:21six weeks of radiation because even
- 43:24after mastectomy there are going
- 43:25to be patients who are going to
- 43:28require postmastectomy radiation.
- 43:29And Lastly that with the current
- 43:32technology and the advances that we have,
- 43:34radiation has really become quite
- 43:36safe and effective, it does.
- 43:38Decrease local and regional
- 43:39recurrences by about 2/3.
- 43:41There's also a survival benefit
- 43:43in some patients,
- 43:44and it's much better tolerated
- 43:46than it was years ago,
- 43:47so I often will have patients
- 43:49who come to me and say,
- 43:52Oh my mother had radiation 20 years ago,
- 43:54but it was awful.
- 43:56It's not the same as it was years ago.
- 43:59Our technology has advanced so
- 44:01much that the vast majority of
- 44:03patients tolerated very well,
- 44:04and if you need it,
- 44:06it is not necessarily something to fear so.
- 44:09Thank you for your time and thank you
- 44:12for calling in this late in the evening.
- 44:14Thank
- 44:14you doctor Mario that was fantastic.
- 44:16Loved it. I actually learned a lot
- 44:18and was almost holding my breath
- 44:19while you were talking about.
- 44:23And now last but certainly
- 44:25not least Doctor on couple
- 44:26Garo talking about again more.
- 44:29You know the amazing changes that
- 44:31are ongoing in medical oncology.
- 44:33We've gotten a whole slew of questions,
- 44:36so once you're done,
- 44:37I'll be asking our panelists for
- 44:39their thoughts and opinions.
- 44:45Good evening, it's a privilege for
- 44:47me to be part of the smilow shares,
- 44:49and Moreover to be part of the same 323.
- 44:53Teammates smile, water for the doctor.
- 44:56Legare and Doctor Moran.
- 44:57I would like to share the screen so
- 45:00Doctor Moran would you mind to Unshare?
- 45:04Yeah. I have unshared.
- 45:09Stop sharing. Yup, there you go.
- 45:15OK.
- 45:30OK, sorry. I am.
- 45:41So in my talk I'm going to focus
- 45:44on some novel treatment options
- 45:46in her to positive and triple
- 45:49negative advanced breast cancer.
- 45:51We do know that not every case of
- 45:55breast cancer is the same as doctor.
- 45:58Legare mentioned.
- 45:58Approximately 70% of the breast
- 46:00cancers are hormonally driven.
- 46:02However, there are other cancers.
- 46:06That may have a different driving
- 46:09pathway that our is called her two
- 46:13and they represent approximately
- 46:1520 to 25% of all breast cancers,
- 46:19while 1015% of breast cancers.
- 46:22I'm sorry.
- 46:24Are considered the triple negative.
- 46:25They do not have expression for estrogen,
- 46:28progesterone, or hard to,
- 46:30and it is important to know
- 46:32which subtype of breast cancer
- 46:35you're dealing with because.
- 46:37Survival and prognosis is different.
- 46:39The best prognosis is for the
- 46:42hormonally driven cancers,
- 46:43but the her two positive,
- 46:45either with your positive ITI or
- 46:48concurrently are negativity as
- 46:50well as the triple negative breast.
- 46:53Cancer may not have the same
- 46:55excellent prognosis.
- 47:00In the last several years we've had
- 47:03tremendous advancements in the treatment
- 47:05of a triple negative breast cancer,
- 47:07and her two positive breast cancer,
- 47:10and I'm going to mention two
- 47:13such advances for each subtype.
- 47:15What is her two positive iti we do know that.
- 47:19Breast normal breast cells and
- 47:21most of the breast cancer cells
- 47:23do have a certain number of.
- 47:26Her two receptors,
- 47:27her stands for human epithelial
- 47:29receptor and in that class we have four
- 47:33different categories for breast cancer.
- 47:35The her two are the most important.
- 47:39So this had two receptors,
- 47:42are transmembrane proteins
- 47:43and when are lagging,
- 47:45the growth factor attaches to the receptor.
- 47:48It induces the dimerization.
- 47:50The pairing of that
- 47:51receptor with another one,
- 47:53and that in turn will activate the
- 47:56internal part of the receptor.
- 47:59This code of tyrosine kinase and it
- 48:02will trigger a sequence of events
- 48:05that would lead to activations
- 48:07of pathways and genes inside the
- 48:10nucleus and ultimately lead to.
- 48:13Pro growth to proliferation in
- 48:15approximately 25% of the breast cancer.
- 48:18We have an over expression of her
- 48:21two receptors and or over expression
- 48:24of the genes the her two genes
- 48:28in the nuclei and that leads to
- 48:31an exuberant activation.
- 48:32If you may say so of the.
- 48:38Proliferative pathways inside the
- 48:40cancer cells that could lead to a more
- 48:43aggressive growth and cancer spread.
- 48:45And the important of this pathway
- 48:48was recognized in the 1980s.
- 48:51And while this pathway confers the
- 48:55cancer monographic aggressiveness,
- 48:56it also gives us the opportunity
- 49:01to interact with it.
- 49:03Two to treat and a big component of
- 49:08that improvement in the breast cancer
- 49:12mortality that Doctor Legare mentioned is.
- 49:16Basicaly due to the advancement in the
- 49:19her two positive breast cancer treatment.
- 49:22So in the late 1990s,
- 49:24the first drug that was approved
- 49:27by FDA was transducer MA.
- 49:29This is a monoclonal antibody that attaches
- 49:33to the her two receptor and basically
- 49:36blocks the proliferative pathway there are.
- 49:40Several mechanisms it could
- 49:42also induce the degradation of
- 49:44the receptor prevents sharing,
- 49:47but nevertheless.
- 49:49The plastic so mad made a tremendous
- 49:52difference in the overall survival of
- 49:55patients with metastatic disease and
- 49:57later it was brought to the earlier.
- 50:01Stages of the breast cancer and
- 50:03significantly improved the chance
- 50:05for cure and decrease risk of
- 50:08recurrence for early stages.
- 50:09Breast cancer in 2012 we had the advent
- 50:13of pertuzumab that blocks the pairing of
- 50:16the her two receptor with the her three.
- 50:19This is the strongest.
- 50:24Excuse me still way of stimulating
- 50:28the her two pathway and together
- 50:31with transducer mom again broad
- 50:34additional benefit for metastatic
- 50:36breast cancer cases patients and now
- 50:40it's also approved for treatment of
- 50:43patients with early stages breast
- 50:47cancer before their surgeries.
- 50:50A newer concept is the antibody
- 50:52drug conjugate,
- 50:52and I'm going to talk in more detail.
- 50:58In the next few minutes.
- 51:00So, this monoclonal antibodies
- 51:02are large molecules that act
- 51:05outside the cell membrane,
- 51:07but we also have a class of drugs
- 51:10that are called targeted tyrosine
- 51:12kinase inhibitors that are smaller
- 51:15molecules taken by mouth that could
- 51:19basically block the thyrogen kinase.
- 51:21The internal part of the heart receptor,
- 51:25and by doing that it basically stopped.
- 51:28They stopped this activation of the.
- 51:31Metabolic pathways and.
- 51:35They do have slight differences,
- 51:37but there are some slight differences
- 51:39between the three compounds and
- 51:41the newest one is to cut in it,
- 51:43and again, I'm going to talk
- 51:45a little bit later about it.
- 51:50So the. Antibody drug
- 51:53conjugate's represent them.
- 51:56Significance advancement in the treatment of.
- 52:01Breast cancer and basically the
- 52:04antibody molecule that is transducer
- 52:08map is loaded with several small
- 52:12molecules of a potent cytostatic
- 52:15or potent chemotherapy that is
- 52:19delivered directly to the cancer cell
- 52:23overexpressing her two receptors.
- 52:26So it's a targeted chemotherapy
- 52:29delivery system.
- 52:31So when it after it attaches
- 52:33to the receptors,
- 52:35it gets internalized in what we
- 52:37call an endo zone the and after an
- 52:40activation of certain enzymes in
- 52:42the what it becomes now the lysosome
- 52:45the chemotherapy medication is.
- 52:50Released inside the cells
- 52:52and kills the cells.
- 52:53So different antibodies have
- 52:55different abilities to release,
- 52:57less or more of this chemotherapy molecules,
- 53:01and we do know that the sum of
- 53:04the chemotherapy can diffuse
- 53:06into the neighborhood.
- 53:08It can diffuse outside the cell and
- 53:11actually killed some other cells
- 53:14in the neighborhood that may not
- 53:16be so strongly her two positive.
- 53:20So this is what we call a
- 53:24bystander killing effect.
- 53:25So the first antibody drug, conjugate,
- 53:28that was approved by FDA in 2012,
- 53:32was trastuzumab, khamsin, or PDM,
- 53:35one and basically it's a molecule
- 53:37of transducer mob with 3.5
- 53:40molecules of maintenance,
- 53:42and that is a very strong cytostatic
- 53:46that would be too toxic to be.
- 53:51I mean to be used as a treatment on its own.
- 53:54So this medication made significant
- 53:57improvement in the outcome of metastatic
- 54:01breast cancer when used in second
- 54:04line after a patient's progress.
- 54:08Usually transducer marban pertuzumab plus
- 54:11attacks in bone backbone chemotherapy.
- 54:14But as of 2019,
- 54:17it got FDA approval also for treatment.
- 54:22Agile and setting up if patients
- 54:25are treated with trastuzumab
- 54:27and pertuzumab and chemotherapy,
- 54:30and they have residual.
- 54:32Disease at the time of the surgery,
- 54:36those die hard cells could be
- 54:39better killed by this targeted
- 54:42delivery of the chemotherapy.
- 54:45In December 2019,
- 54:46FDA gave accelerated approval for a
- 54:49new antibody drug conjugate called
- 54:52transducer Map Direct City Cam.
- 54:55The commercial name is in her too,
- 54:58and while we're not supposed
- 54:59to use commercial names,
- 55:01it's much easier to pronounce.
- 55:03So compared to TDM one,
- 55:06this antibody delivers a much
- 55:09higher payload of chemotherapy.
- 55:11It has eight such molecules attached to it,
- 55:16and what happens the linker
- 55:20that attaches the.
- 55:22The chemotherapy that is a typo.
- 55:25I summarize one inhibitor
- 55:28to the transducer map.
- 55:31It's cleavable.
- 55:32Meaning like it then gets cleaved
- 55:36easier inside the cancer cells and that
- 55:40accounts for a much higher bystander effect.
- 55:44In addition,
- 55:45this molecule has a much higher
- 55:48affinity for the her two receptors
- 55:51compared to the Herceptin,
- 55:53and also to the TDM one.
- 55:57So.
- 55:59They approve all his based on
- 56:02this Destiny Breast 01 trial,
- 56:05which basically was a single arm
- 56:08phase two trial that enrolled
- 56:11112 twelve patients who were
- 56:14heavily pretreated so that means
- 56:17they had received number of.
- 56:20My therapies before the median number
- 56:23was six where there were patients who
- 56:25received as few as two and some other
- 56:28patients who received as many as 29.
- 56:30And in such,
- 56:32a heavily pretreated population,
- 56:34usually the response rate is very low,
- 56:37but in this is the waterfall plot
- 56:40analysis and basically each line
- 56:43represents an individual patient and the
- 56:46length of this bar or line basically
- 56:49reflects the depth of the response,
- 56:52and a picture is worth 1000 words.
- 56:55You can see that the vast majority of
- 56:59patients had a shrinkage in their tumor,
- 57:03so by.
- 57:04We call it stable disease if it's
- 57:09shrinkage less than 30% and significant.
- 57:14Or a partial response if it's
- 57:17more than 30% and progression
- 57:20of when it's more than 15%,
- 57:23so 60.9% of the patients
- 57:26treated with trastuzumab.
- 57:27Dirac stickan achieved response rate for.
- 57:32And 76% of the patients had the control
- 57:36of their disease at six months.
- 57:39This response lasted for at least 14
- 57:41months and not only that, it worked,
- 57:44but it worked fast with a median time
- 57:47to response of 1.6 months, which means,
- 57:51like a little bit more than six weeks.
- 57:55The overall survival in this
- 57:57study has not been reached.
- 57:58The medication is well tolerated mainly
- 58:01with the neutropenia and some fatigue,
- 58:03but there is a particular side
- 58:05effect that requires attention
- 58:07and it's called interstitial lung
- 58:09disease that usually presents with.
- 58:11Shortness of breath and cough and.
- 58:16On the imaging studies it would
- 58:18show some ground glass opacity's,
- 58:20so the doctors do know to monitor
- 58:23for such side effect very carefully.
- 58:26Of note,
- 58:27patients with her two positive
- 58:29disease have a higher propensity
- 58:31for developing brain metastases
- 58:34and such patients are usually
- 58:36excluded from the clinical trials.
- 58:39In this best in in 01 trial,
- 58:4224 patients with stable brain
- 58:45metastases were included and that
- 58:47progression free survival was 18 months
- 58:50and that is absolutely remarkable.
- 58:53But I am glad to say that there
- 58:56is another drug that also got
- 58:59recently approved and that could
- 59:01give us even a better hope for such
- 59:05patients with brain metastasis.
- 59:07And this is the selective tyrosine
- 59:09kinase inhibitor called Tucatinib.
- 59:11And as I said before,
- 59:13it works at the intracellular
- 59:16portion of the pathway.
- 59:18So the her two climb patient,
- 59:21so you had to climb trial randomized
- 59:24612 patients to chemotherapy with
- 59:26trastuzumab and keep site had
- 59:29been with or without Academy.
- 59:32So some patients receive the catnip.
- 59:35Some patients receive the possible and.
- 59:3948 percent of the patients of almost
- 59:43half of them had brain metastases.
- 59:48Somewhere stable and somewhere
- 59:50newly diagnosed but not requiring
- 59:53immediate treatment and some had
- 59:56progression after prior treatment.
- 59:59So the.
- 60:00In the overall population,
- 01:00:02there was a significant improvement
- 01:00:04in the pro Disease Control.
- 01:00:07What we call progression free
- 01:00:09survival with 46% reduction in
- 01:00:11the risk of progression.
- 01:00:13And that translated into an improvement
- 01:00:16in the overall survival with 34%
- 01:00:18reduction in the risk of death.
- 01:00:24When we look at the patients
- 01:00:27with brain metastases,
- 01:00:28the overall response rate was 47%.
- 01:00:31For patients who had.
- 01:00:35The Tucatinib treatment versus
- 01:00:38placebo and that translated into
- 01:00:40an unprecedented improvement in the
- 01:00:43progression free survival at one year.
- 01:00:47Like 75% of the patients were alive
- 01:00:51and with control of their disease
- 01:00:55and also in the overall survival.
- 01:00:58So these two medications transferred
- 01:01:01him up the Rack City can,
- 01:01:03and the Ducati need represent
- 01:01:06major improvements in the
- 01:01:07treatment of the advanced.
- 01:01:09Her two positive breast cancer.
- 01:01:11They are now being studied in more
- 01:01:14and earlier lines of therapy in
- 01:01:17opposing ajibon therapy for the.
- 01:01:22The transducer map the taxi can to
- 01:01:25replace the TDM one or second line
- 01:01:29and also looking at their effecting
- 01:01:32the patullo positive disease.
- 01:01:34So shifting gears to triple
- 01:01:37negative breast cancer,
- 01:01:38we define it by what is what doesn't have
- 01:01:41by the lack of estrogen progesterone
- 01:01:45receptors and her two receptors,
- 01:01:47and it represents 10 to 15% of all
- 01:01:51breast cancer cases more common
- 01:01:53in African American patients
- 01:01:55and those of Hispanic heritage.
- 01:01:57Younger women.
- 01:01:58Those who are BRC A1 mutation carriers.
- 01:02:02We do note that 85% of bracamonte associated
- 01:02:05breast cancers are triple negative.
- 01:02:08And Conversely,
- 01:02:0910 to 15% of the triple negative
- 01:02:12breast cancer patients have BRC
- 01:02:14one mutation and they do have
- 01:02:17a more aggressive behavior,
- 01:02:19but even triple negative breast
- 01:02:21cancer is not the same disease.
- 01:02:24There are different subtypes.
- 01:02:27Researchers from Vanderbilt University.
- 01:02:31It's remarkable research and
- 01:02:33identified several subtypes.
- 01:02:35There were seven initially,
- 01:02:36and they were narrowed down to four,
- 01:02:40and I'm not going to go into details
- 01:02:43about the specifics of each subtype.
- 01:02:46But just to mention that there are
- 01:02:49different genetics and molecular
- 01:02:51differences and there is extensive
- 01:02:54research trying to target.
- 01:02:56Them and find particular.
- 01:03:00Solutions and treatments for
- 01:03:03each breast cancer subtype.
- 01:03:05So we do have breakthrough
- 01:03:07development in the treatment of
- 01:03:09triple negative breast cancer,
- 01:03:12and this is a drug called Sacituzumab movie
- 01:03:15taken that was approved in April of 2024.
- 01:03:19Three front of triple negative breast cancer.
- 01:03:22So this is a targeted antibody
- 01:03:25drug conjugate similar to transfer
- 01:03:27some of their practican.
- 01:03:29But in this case it targets a drop
- 01:03:33two antigen that was found to be
- 01:03:36expressed on many epithelial cancers.
- 01:03:39Such as bladder cancer,
- 01:03:41breast cancer initially thought to be
- 01:03:44specific for triple negative breast cancer,
- 01:03:47but recent research showed that
- 01:03:50actually it's equally expressed on the
- 01:03:53ER positive breast cancers as well,
- 01:03:56so the antibody targets this antigen and
- 01:03:59antibody has a high payload of chemotherapy,
- 01:04:03called SN 38.
- 01:04:05This is.
- 01:04:07Metabolic product over
- 01:04:09chemotherapy that we know we can.
- 01:04:13That is basically used to treat.
- 01:04:18GI malignancy is mainly,
- 01:04:20and it's not necessarily part of
- 01:04:23the armamentarium that we have for
- 01:04:25the triple negative breast cancer.
- 01:04:28So it delivers a novel chemotherapy to
- 01:04:31the triple negative breast cancer cells,
- 01:04:34and what is also particular about
- 01:04:37this compound is that the linker
- 01:04:40is very pH sensitive and that.
- 01:04:43A has a very.
- 01:04:49It is released very easily into
- 01:04:52the cancer cells and also has
- 01:04:56an important bystander effect.
- 01:04:59So this medication was approved
- 01:05:01based on the results of a phase two
- 01:05:05trial where women were treated.
- 01:05:08In third line or above and there
- 01:05:10was a response rate of 35% with.
- 01:05:14Progression free survival or 5.6 months
- 01:05:17and overall survival of 13 months.
- 01:05:20So European Society of Medical
- 01:05:23Oncology in September 2024 S mom
- 01:05:26we the results of the central were
- 01:05:30presented and basically this trial
- 01:05:33compared Gov Itacon versus single
- 01:05:36agent chemotherapy in metastatic
- 01:05:39triple negative breast cancer in
- 01:05:42women who already had at least two
- 01:05:46prior chemotherapy regiments and
- 01:05:48this novel medication was compared.
- 01:05:52To what ever the physician thought
- 01:05:55would be the best possible choice
- 01:05:58for that particular patient.
- 01:06:01And there was a significant improvement
- 01:06:04in the progression free survival
- 01:06:07from 1.7 months to 5.6 months.
- 01:06:10The and there was also an improvement
- 01:06:13in the overall survival,
- 01:06:15so this is the first study that
- 01:06:18showed an improved survival over
- 01:06:21standard of care in triple negative
- 01:06:24breast cancer and the results
- 01:06:27again are unprecedented and this
- 01:06:29drug is going to move to.
- 01:06:33Earlier stages of treatment.
- 01:06:37It is well tolerated with main
- 01:06:39side effects being anemia,
- 01:06:41neutropenia, and diarrhea.
- 01:06:42That is usually very well
- 01:06:45controlled with Imodium.
- 01:06:46So.
- 01:06:49Using the same concept.
- 01:06:52That's targeting different.
- 01:06:56An antigen called leave 1A.
- 01:06:59There is a drug called the.
- 01:07:03Look, that is a map that is in
- 01:07:06clinical trials at and we are
- 01:07:07happy to say that is open at
- 01:07:09Yale through Phase one program.
- 01:07:11And the. We do know that some of
- 01:07:14the triple negative breast cancer.
- 01:07:17Do have a low expression of the
- 01:07:20her two receptors and transducer
- 01:07:22Moderat stickan is being studied
- 01:07:25in this setting as well.
- 01:07:27And the sacituzumab govit econ
- 01:07:29is also studied in ER positive.
- 01:07:34Metastatic breast cancer and again,
- 01:07:36I'm happy to say that we have a clinical
- 01:07:40trial called tropics to open at Yale.
- 01:07:44So over the last decade,
- 01:07:46the advent of immunotherapy has changed
- 01:07:49Natural History of many cancers.
- 01:07:52And obviously there was a question,
- 01:07:55would that make a difference in
- 01:07:58metastatic triple negative breast cancer?
- 01:08:01We do know that body has an innate
- 01:08:04immune system that is supposed to
- 01:08:07protect us against the invaders
- 01:08:09against breast cancer cells,
- 01:08:12and when the normal antigens are recognized,
- 01:08:15the P cells would come and destroy the cells,
- 01:08:20however the cancers.
- 01:08:23Dude, learn to fight back so we do have
- 01:08:27this checkpoint mechanism that basicaly
- 01:08:30also has a good role to prevent the P
- 01:08:35cells of attacking the normal cells.
- 01:08:38But the. Two more cells take advantage
- 01:08:40of that by overexpressing body called
- 01:08:43the program death Ligand and binding
- 01:08:47the OR pedial one receptor and binding
- 01:08:50the PD one receptor on the tumour
- 01:08:53cells and turning off the surveillance
- 01:08:56of the immune system and by doing
- 01:08:59that they managed to grow undetected.
- 01:09:02So Fortunately we do have a new
- 01:09:04class of drugs that are called immune
- 01:09:06checkpoint inhibitors that could block
- 01:09:09either the PDL one receptor or the
- 01:09:11PD one receptors and by doing that.
- 01:09:14The T cells are now allowed to detect
- 01:09:17the cancer cells and destroy them.
- 01:09:21So several such drugs are were
- 01:09:24investigated in, particularly in
- 01:09:26triple negative breast cancer,
- 01:09:28and this single therapy and first
- 01:09:31line setting the response rate
- 01:09:33was not that impressive,
- 01:09:35maybe only in the low 20%.
- 01:09:38But what is intriguing is that
- 01:09:41there are patients that are
- 01:09:44responders who have very durable.
- 01:09:47A response and potentially be cured.
- 01:09:52So.
- 01:09:54Impassion 130 was the first trial
- 01:09:58that basically combined pedia.
- 01:10:01One inhibitor atezolizumab with the
- 01:10:03chemotherapy backbone of NAB paclitaxel.
- 01:10:064.
- 01:10:08Women with the triple negative breast cancer.
- 01:10:14And or locally advanced,
- 01:10:18unresectable breast cancer.
- 01:10:20And. They were treated.
- 01:10:25And the statistics have
- 01:10:28showed the significant.
- 01:10:31Improvement in the duration of the
- 01:10:34Disease Control of more than two months.
- 01:10:37But actually the benefit was seen
- 01:10:40only in the patients who had the PD
- 01:10:44L1 expression positive ITI using the
- 01:10:47specific essay called Ventana SP 142.
- 01:10:50In the clinic,
- 01:10:52in this particular clinical trial,
- 01:10:5340% of the patients had
- 01:10:55the PD L1 positive ITI,
- 01:10:57but we do know that in real life only 20
- 01:11:01to 30% of such patients are positive.
- 01:11:04So the Disease Control translated into
- 01:11:07an improvement in the overall survival
- 01:11:11of 10 months from 15 to 25 months.
- 01:11:15For this pedial one positive population and.
- 01:11:20FDA approved the use of
- 01:11:22alcoholism app and nap.
- 01:11:23Paclitaxel,
- 01:11:24irrespective of the line of therapy.
- 01:11:26But we do not have really.
- 01:11:29We really don't have data to
- 01:11:31know what would be the benefit
- 01:11:34beyond the first line treatment.
- 01:11:37So another study that was presented
- 01:11:40at ASCO 2020 used this time at
- 01:11:43PD one inhibitor called the
- 01:11:46pembrolizumab and combine it with
- 01:11:49different types of chemotherapy.
- 01:11:51There were three different regiments,
- 01:11:54not backlit axle.
- 01:11:57Paclitaxel and Jim Carbo and the patients
- 01:12:01were treated and field progression,
- 01:12:04toxicity or completion of
- 01:12:0635 cycles of treatment.
- 01:12:09And we did see Dan improvement in
- 01:12:12the progression free survival.
- 01:12:14That again was limited to those
- 01:12:17patients who overexpressed the PDL one.
- 01:12:19They used a different.
- 01:12:21Way of describing their positive
- 01:12:24iti's CPS score,
- 01:12:25which looks at the total percent
- 01:12:27of cells that are positive,
- 01:12:29including the tumour cells,
- 01:12:31lymphocytes and macrophages in the tumor.
- 01:12:34So this regimen is not FDA approved yet,
- 01:12:38but it is up for approval,
- 01:12:41and I think the message to take home
- 01:12:45from this study is that you can use
- 01:12:49different chemotherapy backbones,
- 01:12:51different chemotherapy regiments
- 01:12:53in combination with immunotherapy,
- 01:12:55and you can tailor the chemotherapy
- 01:12:58used based on the patients
- 01:13:00toxicities and prior treatments.
- 01:13:05So I'd like to say that there's the
- 01:13:08question why do certain patients stop
- 01:13:12responding to the immunotherapy?
- 01:13:15And there are mechanisms of resistance
- 01:13:18with activation of the Mac or AKT pathways,
- 01:13:22and Fortunately we do have.
- 01:13:26Hitters tyrosine kinases that could turn
- 01:13:29those pathways off and there are some
- 01:13:32early studies that basically combine them.
- 01:13:35Make inhibitor called cobimetinib.
- 01:13:37There is actually approved for
- 01:13:40treatment time of Melanoma with taxol.
- 01:13:43And that other look at is Alyssa Map.
- 01:13:46So basically the same regimen from the
- 01:13:49Impassion 130 trials and early results show
- 01:13:52an excellent control in the tumour burden,
- 01:13:56and very promising response rates.
- 01:13:59So the chemoimmunotherapy was brought
- 01:14:02to earlier phases of treatment in
- 01:14:06new agement setting for women who
- 01:14:10have triple negative breast cancer.
- 01:14:13And are treated with corrective
- 01:14:15intent before the surgery and there
- 01:14:18was a significant improvement in
- 01:14:20the rate of pathological complete
- 01:14:22response and event free survival
- 01:14:25without significant increase in the.
- 01:14:29Adverse events this regimen
- 01:14:33is not in the approved yet.
- 01:14:35Waiting additional data
- 01:14:37in the overall survival.
- 01:14:39So I tried to make the point that
- 01:14:43important breakthrough developments.
- 01:14:46And that we do have important
- 01:14:48breakthrough developments in the
- 01:14:50treatment of her two positive and
- 01:14:53triple negative breast cancer,
- 01:14:54the treatment has to be personalized based
- 01:14:57on the cancer subtypes and different
- 01:15:00molecular characteristics of the two more,
- 01:15:02but also looking at the
- 01:15:05patients comorbidities,
- 01:15:05prior treatments and patients preference and.
- 01:15:09Participation in clinical trials is very
- 01:15:11important to continue to improve the
- 01:15:14outcome of different types of breast cancer.
- 01:15:17I am very happy to say that we have
- 01:15:20an expanding large list of clinical
- 01:15:23trials for all subtypes and all
- 01:15:26stages of breast cancer at Yale.
- 01:15:29And we are all a team fighting for hope and
- 01:15:34also fighting for curing breast cancer.
- 01:15:38And these are some contact information
- 01:15:42if you choose to call us after
- 01:15:46this meeting is over.
- 01:15:48Thank you.
- 01:15:50Thank you so much Doctor Bulgar that was
- 01:15:53quite a Tour de force in the latest in
- 01:15:56uncut medical oncology and drug therapy.
- 01:15:58We actually don't have a ton of time
- 01:16:00but there were so many questions.
- 01:16:02I just love this panel and more
- 01:16:05importantly the attendees who really
- 01:16:07took so much time out of their evening
- 01:16:09to stay with us and listen to what
- 01:16:12smilow and our Cancer Center is doing.
- 01:16:14So this is almost like speed dating.
- 01:16:16I'm going to fire off some questions if.
- 01:16:20To our panelists and hopefully just keep
- 01:16:22those answers as quick as possible.
- 01:16:24But this is really all of our.
- 01:16:27Attendees really deserve answers
- 01:16:29to their questions,
- 01:16:31which I tried to do in the
- 01:16:34background couple for Doctor Moran.
- 01:16:36One is a question on angiosarcoma
- 01:16:39after treatment for a radiation
- 01:16:41therapy 10 years after mastectomy.
- 01:16:44This comes from an Peterson and from her mom
- 01:16:47who required a pretty extensive resection.
- 01:16:51What percentage of patients
- 01:16:53develop osteosarcomas,
- 01:16:54and is there a gene that can
- 01:16:57differentiate with that?
- 01:16:59And kind of moving along those
- 01:17:01lines is from those radiation
- 01:17:04damage the skin and tissue,
- 01:17:07thus making reconstruction different
- 01:17:08difficult after mastectomy.
- 01:17:10OK, so to answer the first question,
- 01:17:13yes, second malignancy in the
- 01:17:16radiation field can occur.
- 01:17:18It is pretty rare we quote the number
- 01:17:22of .01% at 10 years and I think
- 01:17:26you know that's probably accurate.
- 01:17:28At best I've seen maybe 2 in
- 01:17:31my 20 year career of a sarcoma
- 01:17:34that was radiation induced,
- 01:17:36so it's unfortunate there isn't
- 01:17:38any way for us to be able to
- 01:17:41identify those patients other than
- 01:17:43maybe possibly the ATM mutation,
- 01:17:45which isn't necessarily linked
- 01:17:47to sarcomas per se,
- 01:17:49but they do have significantly
- 01:17:51more toxicity from the radiation,
- 01:17:53and it could be that they have a
- 01:17:56higher incidence of 2nd malignancies
- 01:17:58related to the radiation.
- 01:18:00Other repair mechanisms are not
- 01:18:02as established as someone who
- 01:18:05doesn't carry that mutation.
- 01:18:07The second question,
- 01:18:09as far as reconstruction,
- 01:18:11that is a very,
- 01:18:13very excellent question and we
- 01:18:15deal with this all the time.
- 01:18:18Yes, radiation does cause the image,
- 01:18:21and for this reason,
- 01:18:23when you undergo a mastectomy and
- 01:18:26then get radiation and then have
- 01:18:29reconstruction in the delayed setting.
- 01:18:32Or what needs to happen is
- 01:18:34a couple of things.
- 01:18:35One is that you want to wait at
- 01:18:38least six months or so to allow the
- 01:18:40skin to completely heal 2 is that
- 01:18:43you want to have an experienced
- 01:18:45a plastic surgeon who knows.
- 01:18:48Has experienced with the radiation
- 01:18:50and how that tissue looks like Inter
- 01:18:54operatively and 3rd is that unless
- 01:18:56you've had an expander place you
- 01:18:59really can't do an implant based
- 01:19:01reconstruction and so for that
- 01:19:03reason most of those patients who
- 01:19:06have delayed reconstruction and
- 01:19:08haven't had an expander placed will
- 01:19:11have to have a autologous flap and
- 01:19:13what that means is just putting
- 01:19:16in tissue from somewhere else,
- 01:19:18whether it be their abdomen or
- 01:19:21their back or their butt so.
- 01:19:25Thank
- 01:19:25you, I'm kind of going back to an earlier
- 01:19:28and just more generalized question on.
- 01:19:31You know how confident can we be
- 01:19:33when you haven't really dense breast
- 01:19:35tissue on mammogram and ultrasound
- 01:19:37in terms of detection of cancer?
- 01:19:39And how can women self check
- 01:19:42outside of their annual mammogram?
- 01:19:45Especially when the some of the
- 01:19:47recommendations for self breast
- 01:19:48exam are no longer recommended.
- 01:19:50This is just open to any and
- 01:19:51all of our panelists.
- 01:19:58Bob, no.
- 01:20:00Sure. So in terms of the dense breast tissue,
- 01:20:04you know we know that you know that's common.
- 01:20:08Maybe half of women have breast density.
- 01:20:11It's categorized and defined, but we know
- 01:20:14that can decrease sensitivity for mammogram.
- 01:20:16We know younger women are more likely to have
- 01:20:19you know denser breast tissue, but older
- 01:20:22women have denser breast tissue as well,
- 01:20:24so we know there's some limited sensitivity.
- 01:20:27We still know that mammography is the
- 01:20:29one tool that's been shown to define and
- 01:20:32reduce mortality from breast cancer,
- 01:20:34so we still do use mammogram.
- 01:20:36I would say that these days and we're
- 01:20:38fortunate United States where pretty
- 01:20:40much all using digital mammogram.
- 01:20:42And most of us are also using Tomo synthesis,
- 01:20:45which gives us a little bit more
- 01:20:47sensitivity still in terms of getting
- 01:20:49more of a 3D picture of the breast and
- 01:20:52then just to comment on ultrasound,
- 01:20:54I usually tell my patients that
- 01:20:56ultrasound might pick up.
- 01:20:58Maybe 3 or 4, maybe 4% per thousand
- 01:21:00more more breast cancer,
- 01:21:02so it's something that you know.
- 01:21:04Some women choose is all this.
- 01:21:06No, that's in part political.
- 01:21:07But when you look at the medical
- 01:21:10aspect of it,
- 01:21:11it's an option for women with dense,
- 01:21:13dense breast tissue.
- 01:21:14And we know that MRI is out there
- 01:21:16and is used selectively in high
- 01:21:18risk populations like germline
- 01:21:19mutations or other populations.
- 01:21:21And we know that that could be considered
- 01:21:24the gold standard in terms of sensitivity.
- 01:21:28But we use it less for multiple reasons.
- 01:21:30That was the second part of that question,
- 01:21:33I'm sorry.
- 01:21:35In terms of self breast exams,
- 01:21:37thoughts on that? Yeah, you
- 01:21:40know the data. Hasn't shown us that
- 01:21:42that breast self exam you know improve,
- 01:21:45you know survival or as relates
- 01:21:47to breast cancer and and certainly
- 01:21:49some women still choose to do that
- 01:21:52and it's their right to do that.
- 01:21:54And I would say that if one is
- 01:21:56doing that maybe just being trained
- 01:21:58to do it most effectively but we
- 01:22:01don't have necessarily other tools,
- 01:22:03But that's not something that we.
- 01:22:06Generally recommend those.
- 01:22:07Certainly someone certainly
- 01:22:08choose to do that.
- 01:22:11That that we cannot really rely on the
- 01:22:14breast exam to detect the breast cancer,
- 01:22:17and that's the value of the screening
- 01:22:20mammogram to detect them way before
- 01:22:23the breast cancers become palpable.
- 01:22:25American Cancer Society discourages self
- 01:22:27breast exam as routine detection method,
- 01:22:30but enciende guidelines do include a
- 01:22:33recommendation for what we call breast
- 01:22:36awareness because it is very important for
- 01:22:39women to know how their breast feel like.
- 01:22:43It also for premenopausal women the best
- 01:22:45time to check would be under 10 days
- 01:22:47after the onset of the menstrual periods,
- 01:22:50when there are less hormonal changes
- 01:22:52in the breast and we do know that 10 to
- 01:22:5615% of the breast cancers are diagnosed
- 01:22:58because women do find a lump in the breast.
- 01:23:01So I think that while never say I'm
- 01:23:04just going to rely on the breast exam,
- 01:23:07go for the screening mammogram.
- 01:23:08I do encourage my patients to have
- 01:23:11a breast awareness and be aware of.
- 01:23:13How their breast tissue feels like.
- 01:23:15Yeah, I agree with that as well,
- 01:23:18and I also tell patients for anyone
- 01:23:20that's had radiation as they
- 01:23:22are finishing their radiation.
- 01:23:24I tell them that during the first
- 01:23:26six months post radiation that they
- 01:23:28should actually do a breast exam,
- 01:23:30not to be alarmed,
- 01:23:31but that all the changes that
- 01:23:33they're feeling is the scar
- 01:23:35tissue that's developing.
- 01:23:37Because with radiation you develop
- 01:23:38scar tissue just like you do with surgery,
- 01:23:41and it's just an opportunity for them
- 01:23:43to learn what their new breast feels like,
- 01:23:46so that down the road.
- 01:23:48They're not alarmed if they
- 01:23:50suddenly check their breasts at
- 01:23:52one year and and suddenly feel
- 01:23:54lumps and bumps because the vast
- 01:23:56majority of them are normal.
- 01:23:59And this is for two things from Caitlin.
- 01:24:02One is, she said, please do self checks
- 01:24:06and that's how she found her cancer again.
- 01:24:09Absolutely, if a woman feels comfortable
- 01:24:12with their own breast exams and
- 01:24:15seeing any changes of noticing them,
- 01:24:17I 100% supportive of doing self breast exams.
- 01:24:21She also had a really
- 01:24:24thoughtful question about.
- 01:24:26Stage 2A triple positive breast
- 01:24:27cancer with no lymph nodes.
- 01:24:29What are the thoughts on neural
- 01:24:31links and also thoughts on who?
- 01:24:33For ectomy on a 36 year old female on
- 01:24:36tamoxifen for the above mentioned diagnosis.
- 01:24:42Want me to comment on that?
- 01:24:45The you know neural links that you know,
- 01:24:47I believe you referring to Noor
- 01:24:49Atnip which is an oral sort of pan.
- 01:24:52Her two tyrosine kinase inhibitor.
- 01:24:54And that was studied, and it seemed to be.
- 01:24:59More effective,
- 01:25:00perhaps in the ER positive group,
- 01:25:02I believe that was the EXANET trial.
- 01:25:06It's oral, I think it was taken for a year.
- 01:25:10Has some pretty significant side effects
- 01:25:12in terms of especially diarrhea,
- 01:25:13but there's ways to sort of try to
- 01:25:16preempt that prophylaxis against it.
- 01:25:18I believe that trial also did include.
- 01:25:23Women who had new regiment therapy and there
- 01:25:26was a similar trend in terms of benefit.
- 01:25:29Interesting thing these to my not to
- 01:25:31my as I recall is that in that trial
- 01:25:34women hadn't seen Pertuzumab which is
- 01:25:37now sort of a standard complemented
- 01:25:39as Doctor Boger was showing.
- 01:25:41As earlier with Herceptin which
- 01:25:42is also called trust.
- 01:25:44Choose a map in these sort of neoadjuvant
- 01:25:46and then sometimes following into the
- 01:25:49advanced setting so there is some data there,
- 01:25:52but there's not really data.
- 01:25:53Looking at that agent.
- 01:25:55In the setting of prior
- 01:25:57exposure to produce in abduls.
- 01:25:58To my knowledge,
- 01:26:00in addition to trust him then.
- 01:26:03And then the second part,
- 01:26:04Doctor Bulgaro,
- 01:26:04did you want to comment on the second bar?
- 01:26:07Sure, so the IT is well established
- 01:26:10based on the large softex trial that
- 01:26:13young women do benefit from ovarian
- 01:26:16suppression. That is done with.
- 01:26:22With drugs like Zola decks or can
- 01:26:25settle in and in addition to oral
- 01:26:29anti hormonal treatment, now the.
- 01:26:33Removal of, I mean that basically puts
- 01:26:35the patients into a chemical menopause.
- 01:26:38There is the option of a surgical menopause,
- 01:26:41particularly if there is a genetic
- 01:26:43predisposition for ovarian cancer,
- 01:26:45but that is an irreversible option, you know.
- 01:26:47So I think that it has to be discussed
- 01:26:50with your treating physician,
- 01:26:52the pros and cons of prophylactic
- 01:26:55bulfer ectomy.
- 01:26:55If there is a cancer predisposition,
- 01:26:58genes that would increase the risk
- 01:27:00for ovarian cancer and someone is.
- 01:27:02Delete sure that is done conceiving.
- 01:27:07Then, prophylactically for Ectomy
- 01:27:09is an option but otherwise
- 01:27:12ovarian suppression with this.
- 01:27:15Every three months injections is the
- 01:27:17standard of care in addition to oral,
- 01:27:19anti estrogen therapy and then
- 01:27:20you have the tamoxifen or even
- 01:27:22better than automatic inhibitor.
- 01:27:27So much first of all to our
- 01:27:29panelists around of applause.
- 01:27:31Although we won't be able to hear
- 01:27:34it from her doctor Bulgarella
- 01:27:36Garian Moran for you know, really.
- 01:27:393 state of the art fantastic talks.
- 01:27:42And here at Yale and the Smilow
- 01:27:44Cancer Center at Water for Dell,
- 01:27:47NM westerly, it was a great evening.
- 01:27:50And really more importantly to
- 01:27:52our attendees or cancer survivors,
- 01:27:54those are going through this right now.
- 01:27:58Your questions were super thoughtful.
- 01:28:00I tried to answer some of them
- 01:28:02while our panelists were giving
- 01:28:04their giving their talks.
- 01:28:05This has been recorded and
- 01:28:07you can go back to it.
- 01:28:09And of course,
- 01:28:10we're always here for you and
- 01:28:12happy to answer any questions.
- 01:28:17Thank you so much for a wonderful
- 01:28:19evening and stay healthy.
- 01:28:21Take care guys, thank you.
- 01:28:22Thank you, thank you.