Skip to Main Content

Thyroid Nodule Management

August 10, 2020
  • 00:00Support for Yale Cancer Answers
  • 00:02comes from AstraZeneca, working to
  • 00:05eliminate cancer as a cause of death.
  • 00:08Learn more at astrazeneca-us.com.
  • 00:12Welcome to Yale Cancer
  • 00:13Answers with your host
  • 00:15Doctor Anees Chagpar.
  • 00:18Yale Cancer Answers features the
  • 00:20latest information on cancer care by
  • 00:22welcoming oncologists and specialists
  • 00:24who are on the forefront of the
  • 00:27battle to fight cancer. This week,
  • 00:28it's a conversation about thyroid
  • 00:30cancer and the management of
  • 00:32thyroid nodules with Doctor Grace Lee.
  • 00:34Doctor Lee is an assistant professor
  • 00:36in the section of endocrinology and
  • 00:38metabolism at the Yale School of
  • 00:40Medicine where Doctor Schwartz is the
  • 00:42John Slade Eli Professor of obstetrics,
  • 00:44gynecology and Reproductive Sciences.
  • 00:48Doctor Lee, my first question is
  • 00:50can you tell us a little bit about
  • 00:52yourself and your area of expertise?
  • 00:54What cancers do you treat?
  • 00:56What's your role at the Veterans
  • 00:58Administration Hospital?
  • 01:00So as you mentioned,
  • 01:02I'm assistant professor of Medicine in
  • 01:04the section of endocrinology at Yale.
  • 01:06There I teach Endocrinology Fellows,
  • 01:08medical residents as well
  • 01:10as medical students.
  • 01:11I'm also a clinical endocrinologist
  • 01:13at the Veterans Affairs Connecticut
  • 01:15healthcare system for the VA.
  • 01:16I serve veterans at both the West Haven,
  • 01:19and Newington locations.
  • 01:21My areas of expertise include
  • 01:22thyroid nodules, thyroid cancer,
  • 01:25along with other metabolic bone diseases.
  • 01:28I also practice general endocrinology.
  • 01:32How common is thyroid cancer,
  • 01:34especially in veterans?
  • 01:35And how is it typically diagnosed?
  • 01:37Are there any symptoms that
  • 01:39people should be aware of?
  • 01:41In general, I can tell you
  • 01:43about the thyroid itself.
  • 01:44Not a lot of people know where
  • 01:47the thyroid is, so let's start
  • 01:49off by saying where that is.
  • 01:51It's a gland that's very
  • 01:53important to the body.
  • 01:54It's in the front of the neck and
  • 01:57is right on top of your windpipe.
  • 02:01You know when you ask about
  • 02:03how common thyroid cancer is,
  • 02:05it really depends on the type of
  • 02:07thyroid cancer that we're talking about.
  • 02:09And mainly there's about four
  • 02:11different types of thyroid cancer,
  • 02:13the most common being
  • 02:15papillary thyroid cancer,
  • 02:16and that's about 15 in every 100,000
  • 02:18people an this being the most common
  • 02:21type of cancer is actually also the
  • 02:23most benign type of thyroid cancer.
  • 02:26I shouldn't say benign,
  • 02:27the least aggressive of all
  • 02:29different types of thyroid cancer.
  • 02:31The more aggressive type would
  • 02:33be considered something called
  • 02:34anaplastic thyroid cancer,
  • 02:35which Fortunately is only less
  • 02:37than 3% of the different types
  • 02:39of thyroid cancer that exists.
  • 02:41You asked about symptoms that people
  • 02:43should be aware of and how it's diagnosed.
  • 02:45Typically somebody may notice
  • 02:47a lump in their neck,
  • 02:48which can be either from a
  • 02:50Mass in the thyroid or from an
  • 02:53abnormal lymph node in the neck,
  • 02:55or an enlarged lymph node.
  • 02:57Another way it's typically diagnoses,
  • 02:58actually, incidentally,
  • 02:59for example,
  • 03:00if somebody has a.
  • 03:01Car accident and has a
  • 03:03cat scan for their neck.
  • 03:04They might be surprised to find
  • 03:06out that they have thyroid nodules,
  • 03:08but actually they are very common and
  • 03:10thyroid cancer is actually a very
  • 03:12small percentage of thyroid nodules.
  • 03:14But those are the main different
  • 03:16types of thyroid cancer and chances
  • 03:18are if you're diagnosed with thyroid
  • 03:20cancer it is probably going to
  • 03:22be papillary thyroid cancer.
  • 03:26I was very interested to see a
  • 03:29difference between women and men in
  • 03:31terms of the incidence of thyroid cancer.
  • 03:33My impression is that women now have
  • 03:35about 3 times as many cancers as men,
  • 03:38but it seems to be less deadly in women.
  • 03:41Can you talk to us a little bit
  • 03:44about how this phenomenon may occur
  • 03:46and what should women be aware of,
  • 03:49particularly during
  • 03:50reproductive age?
  • 03:52It's not exactly known why that's true.
  • 03:55Some people think that women
  • 03:56come under the care
  • 03:59of providers more than men do,
  • 04:01and it's true that in men it seems to be
  • 04:04more of an aggressive
  • 04:07cancer, however,
  • 04:08it's all individual based on
  • 04:11the patient and that doesn't necessarily
  • 04:13mean that all men are going to have
  • 04:15poor prognoses.
  • 04:18I forgot to mention earlier,
  • 04:20you mentioned what other
  • 04:23symptoms that women should watch out
  • 04:25for and men should watch out for.
  • 04:27In addition to looking for lumps in the neck,
  • 04:30which you may just find by feeling your neck
  • 04:32you can actually, as the disease progresses,
  • 04:35have compressive symptoms.
  • 04:38So symptoms where in the neck
  • 04:40the mass in the thyroid is large,
  • 04:43it can push on different structures.
  • 04:45For example, it can make it difficult
  • 04:47to swallow or breathe.
  • 04:48It can also actually cause a horse voice.
  • 04:51There's an important nerve that
  • 04:53travels near the thyroid called the
  • 04:54recurrent laryngeal nerve, and if that
  • 04:57is somehow invaded or pushed upon,
  • 04:59that can cause a horse voice.
  • 05:00In addition to that, when it's very large,
  • 05:03if you're lying flat,
  • 05:04people actually feel like
  • 05:06they're choking, but again,
  • 05:07these are more advanced forms
  • 05:09of the cancer and
  • 05:10not typically in the very early stages.
  • 05:14I noticed that during pregnancy,
  • 05:16especially thyroid nodules in
  • 05:18thyroid cancer can present in women
  • 05:23yet they seem to be very low grade.
  • 05:26Can you tell us a little bit
  • 05:29about that phenomenon?
  • 05:30Thyroid cancer in pregnancy does happen.
  • 05:33I would say that in most cases when
  • 05:36this occurs, as long as it's what we
  • 05:39think is papillary thyroid cancer,
  • 05:41we typically do not like to
  • 05:43operate on pregnant women.
  • 05:45An OB I'm sure would feel the same
  • 05:48and we will monitor the nodule
  • 05:50and recommend surgery
  • 05:51ideally after the birth of the child.
  • 05:54However, I would say in rare cases if
  • 05:57something like anaplastic is found,
  • 05:59which I've never had happened
  • 06:00to me or my patients,
  • 06:02but if that were to happen, management,
  • 06:05I assume would be different,
  • 06:06but typically because the cancers
  • 06:08tend to be less aggressive,
  • 06:10we try to put off surgery for
  • 06:12the thyroid in someone who's
  • 06:14pregnant.
  • 06:17And for veterans in the Vietnam War,
  • 06:19of course, Agent Orange became an issue
  • 06:21and I know that there's one recent
  • 06:24study that suggested that there was
  • 06:27a 24 % relative risk measure
  • 06:29or increased risk of thyroid cancers,
  • 06:32and those exposed to Agent Orange.
  • 06:34Is this still a problem for our
  • 06:37Vietnam Veterans today and are
  • 06:39veterans from the Middle East exposed
  • 06:42to increased risk for thyroid cancer?
  • 06:44So those are all
  • 06:46great questions.
  • 06:47I can't tell you the exact
  • 06:49answer to that, although I can say that if
  • 06:52there's any type of radiation exposure,
  • 06:54especially at a younger age,
  • 06:57that does increase
  • 06:58someone's risk of thyroid cancer,
  • 07:00and typically we think of incidents
  • 07:03like Chernobyl or
  • 07:04nuclear accidents that occur.
  • 07:05So any agents that are used that
  • 07:08potentially could have radioactivity.
  • 07:10There are also certain explosive devices
  • 07:12that may have involved radiation.
  • 07:15Anything like that.
  • 07:16If you're in contact with that it
  • 07:18can certainly increase your
  • 07:19risk of thyroid cancer, yes.
  • 07:23And what are the treatment
  • 07:26options available to patients?
  • 07:29So in terms of treatment in
  • 07:31patients who have what's called the
  • 07:33differentiated thyroid cancers,
  • 07:34which are the very well developed cancers
  • 07:37we mentioned, papillary thyroid cancer,
  • 07:39follicular thyroid cancer is another type.
  • 07:41The main treatment actually is
  • 07:43surgery to remove the thyroid
  • 07:45cancer that's present and luckily
  • 07:47we have specialist surgeons who
  • 07:49can provide this kind of surgery.
  • 07:51People who have high volumes of
  • 07:53these types of patients to work on,
  • 07:56they tend to have minimal complications.
  • 07:58So really surgery is the mainstay
  • 08:02treatment for thyroid cancer.
  • 08:03In terms of types of thyroid surgeries,
  • 08:05you can either do a total thyroidectomy
  • 08:07which is to take out the entire thyroid
  • 08:10gland or a thyroidectomy
  • 08:12to remove just half the gland
  • 08:15depending on where and how large the
  • 08:17tumor is will determine the surgeons
  • 08:19approach in whether they'll take out
  • 08:22the entire gland or half the gland
  • 08:24and then in addition to that there can
  • 08:26be extra surgery called a dissection
  • 08:28to take out any affected lymph nodes,
  • 08:31typically in the neck area
  • 08:33in the middle of the neck
  • 08:35where the thyroid is,
  • 08:36but then also on the sides of the neck.
  • 08:39So actually one of the things that's
  • 08:41really important before somebody
  • 08:42has surgery for thyroid cancer is to
  • 08:44have a neck ultrasound looking at
  • 08:46all the lymph nodes including the
  • 08:48sides of the neck so that the surgeon
  • 08:50can plan the appropriate operation
  • 08:52and really have the best outcome and
  • 08:54not have to go again
  • 08:55for surgery.
  • 08:56I understand that there is some
  • 08:59controversy about how extensive
  • 09:00the surgery should be.
  • 09:01What would be the difference between
  • 09:04a partial thyroidectomy versus the
  • 09:06complete removal of a gland in terms
  • 09:07of the patient and her side affects?
  • 09:10So that's a good question. In
  • 09:12terms of total thyroidectomy which
  • 09:13is taking up the entire gland,
  • 09:15actually in both cases I should probably
  • 09:18talk about what the risks are in
  • 09:20both and then kind of separate them.
  • 09:22So a risk of course in any procedure
  • 09:24would be infection or bleeding,
  • 09:26but in particular to thyroid surgery is that
  • 09:29there could be damage to that
  • 09:32nerve that we mentioned earlier,
  • 09:34the recurrent laryngeal nerve which could
  • 09:36actually cause a permanent or temporary
  • 09:39hoarse voice for someone.
  • 09:41Actually, that can be a big change
  • 09:43in their life, especially someone
  • 09:45who's a singer or their vocation
  • 09:47includes speaking and giving lectures,
  • 09:49for example.
  • 09:51In terms of other side effects,
  • 09:54right behind the thyroid gland
  • 09:55are tiny little rice grain sized
  • 09:57glands called parathyroid glands.
  • 09:59And
  • 10:00even though they're very small,
  • 10:02they are very important in
  • 10:03controlling the body's calcium level,
  • 10:05and as you know,
  • 10:06things like really like the heart,
  • 10:08for example,
  • 10:09rely on important calcium
  • 10:10concentration so you know those
  • 10:12glands are essential to the body.
  • 10:14And it takes a very skilled surgeon
  • 10:16to make sure that those are not
  • 10:18harmed or the blood supply to those
  • 10:21glands are not harmed as well.
  • 10:23So one of the complications can
  • 10:24be an under active parathyroid
  • 10:25gland or parathyroid glands
  • 10:27that aren't functioning properly.
  • 10:29So I would say that
  • 10:31in particular,
  • 10:31that parathyroid effect would be
  • 10:33a higher risk in patients with a
  • 10:36total thyroidectomy versus only
  • 10:37half of the thyroid being removed.
  • 10:39But even then the risk is actually very
  • 10:42quite low in patients who have both
  • 10:45these procedures in experienced hands.
  • 10:47So I really don't worry
  • 10:49about that for my patients.
  • 10:50It sounds like experience is
  • 10:53a major issue and you really want
  • 10:55to be sure to have a surgeon who
  • 10:58does a lot of these surgeries on a
  • 11:01routine basis
  • 11:04if a total thyroidectomy is
  • 11:07performed. What additional
  • 11:08replacement therapies are necessary
  • 11:10for the patient versus the
  • 11:12partial thyroidectomy.
  • 11:13Good question, in
  • 11:14patients who have only part
  • 11:16of their thyroid removed,
  • 11:17which is usually going to
  • 11:19be half of the thyroid,
  • 11:20they actually have a chance of not
  • 11:22needing thyroid hormone after surgery.
  • 11:24It's interesting the other half of
  • 11:26the thyroid gland can build enough
  • 11:28response that they can make extra
  • 11:30thyroid hormone so you don't have
  • 11:31to take the pills after the surgery,
  • 11:33but that's not always the case and
  • 11:35so I would say if you're going in
  • 11:38and you know that you're going to
  • 11:40have half your thyroid removed,
  • 11:42I would expect that you may need
  • 11:44to take a pill afterwards with
  • 11:46the whole thyroid being removed.
  • 11:48You'll definitely need to have
  • 11:49thyroid hormone therapy afterwards,
  • 11:51and that's usually in the form of
  • 11:53something called Levothyroxine.
  • 11:54This thyroid hormone would be
  • 11:56a life long treatment because,
  • 11:58as we mentioned earlier,
  • 11:59the thyroid has lots of effects
  • 12:01in the body and you really can't
  • 12:03live without thyroid hormone.
  • 12:05Well, you mentioned earlier also that
  • 12:07most of the thyroid cancers that
  • 12:09we're seeing are low grade cancers.
  • 12:11Are additional treatments necessary
  • 12:12for high grade cancers or for
  • 12:15cancers that have spread to
  • 12:17local lymph nodes or beyond
  • 12:19that?
  • 12:21Yes, for those types of cancers we also offer
  • 12:24something called radioactive iodine
  • 12:26therapy and I think that this is
  • 12:28very what we would call a
  • 12:31targeted therapy because a thyroid
  • 12:33gland is really good at absorbing
  • 12:36iodine and we take advantage of that.
  • 12:38That's
  • 12:40radioactive and what can happen is
  • 12:42the patient when they take radioactive
  • 12:45iodine that iodine can go to
  • 12:47all parts of the body that
  • 12:49have thyroid tissue,
  • 12:50whether it be in your lungs or other parts,
  • 12:52where it may have spread all
  • 12:54they have to do is take the pill
  • 12:56and it will go to both the neck
  • 12:59area where there is probably little
  • 13:01bits of thyroid cells left behind
  • 13:03and then also to the lungs
  • 13:05if there is spread
  • 13:06of the cancer to the lungs,
  • 13:08so instead of
  • 13:10a general chemotherapy,
  • 13:11it's really a targeted therapy
  • 13:12to that thyroid tissue and that
  • 13:14is sort of the beauty of
  • 13:16the treatment.
  • 13:16Are there any additional side
  • 13:18effects that would be expected with
  • 13:20radioactive iodine being
  • 13:21injected?
  • 13:22We think at low doses,
  • 13:25really patients tolerate it very well
  • 13:27an the biggest complaint that I usually get
  • 13:30about it is fatigue or the fact that
  • 13:32they have to actually be on something
  • 13:34called a low iodine diet beforehand and
  • 13:37the reasoning for the low iodine diet
  • 13:39is to make your body hungry for iodine,
  • 13:42so that will take up the
  • 13:44iodine to the thyroid
  • 13:47tissue where it's widespread
  • 13:49in terms of side effects.
  • 13:51Some people do get dry mouth,
  • 13:53you can get watery eyes.
  • 13:55Some people get sort of this
  • 13:57inflammation of the stomach and these
  • 13:59can be either temporary or permanent,
  • 14:02but typically the stomach effect
  • 14:04is very limited and goes away.
  • 14:07And in rare cases, at higher doses,
  • 14:10there is a concern for other
  • 14:11malignancies occurring such as leukemia.
  • 14:13But again,
  • 14:14those risks are minimal and typically
  • 14:16with higher doses of radioactive iodine.
  • 14:18So all in all,
  • 14:19patients really usually tolerate
  • 14:21radioactive iodine rather well,
  • 14:22and if patients are complaining
  • 14:24most about the low iodine diet,
  • 14:26it tells you that the effects
  • 14:28usually are not that bad.
  • 14:30We're going to take a
  • 14:32short break for a medical minute.
  • 14:35Please stay tuned to learn
  • 14:36more about thyroid cancer
  • 14:38and the management of thyroid
  • 14:40nodules with Doctor Grace Lee.
  • 14:42Support for Yale Cancer Answers
  • 14:45comes from AstraZeneca providing
  • 14:47important treatment options for
  • 14:49various types and stages of cancer.
  • 14:52More information at astrazeneca-us.com.
  • 14:56This is a medical minute about lung cancer.
  • 15:00More than 85% of lung cancer diagnosis
  • 15:02are related to smoking and quitting even
  • 15:05after decades of use can significantly
  • 15:08reduce your risk of developing lung
  • 15:10cancer for lung cancer patients.
  • 15:12Clinical trials are currently under
  • 15:14way to test innovative new treatments.
  • 15:16Advances are being made by utilizing
  • 15:19targeted therapies and immunotherapy's
  • 15:22the BATTLE 2 trial aims to learn
  • 15:24if a drug or combination of drugs
  • 15:26based on personal biomarkers can
  • 15:28help to control non small cell lung cancer.
  • 15:31More information is available
  • 15:34at yalecancercenter.org.
  • 15:35You're listening to Connecticut public radio.
  • 15:40Welcome back to Yale Cancer Answers.
  • 15:42This is doctor Peter Schwartz
  • 15:44and I'm joined tonight by
  • 15:46my guest Doctor Grace Lee
  • 15:48and we are discussing thyroid
  • 15:51cancer and the management of thyroid nodules.
  • 15:54So doctor Lee, what are thyroid nodules?
  • 15:56How are they managed?
  • 15:58Can they be cancerous?
  • 15:59What causes them?
  • 16:01Thyroid nodules are actually nodularity of
  • 16:03the thyroid tissue so I describe it
  • 16:07as little balls within your thyroid.
  • 16:09They're very common and actually can
  • 16:11be president in up to 68% of
  • 16:14adults, if you look at adults with ultrasound
  • 16:16and they actually increase with age,
  • 16:18they are often found
  • 16:20incidentally most of the time.
  • 16:22How I see patients as referrals is that
  • 16:24they were found for another reason.
  • 16:26For example,
  • 16:27they had a carotid ultrasound to
  • 16:29look at their arteries and
  • 16:31happen to find a thyroid nodule,
  • 16:33and then I end up seeing those patients.
  • 16:35And we mentioned earlier another
  • 16:38time is when people have CAT scans
  • 16:40for other reasons of their neck
  • 16:42and they find the thyroid nodules.
  • 16:44And typically,
  • 16:45the way to best evaluate them is
  • 16:48actually a thyroid ultrasound.
  • 16:50Most of these nodules are benign and
  • 16:52I think that's the biggest message I
  • 16:54want to say is that if somebody tells
  • 16:57you that you have a thyroid nodule,
  • 17:00the first thing is not to panic.
  • 17:02There actually very common and only
  • 17:05about four to 6 1/2% of these thyroid
  • 17:07nodules are cancerous in terms of who
  • 17:10is at risk for these thyroid
  • 17:12cancers they are usually people who have had
  • 17:15radiation to the head or neck area,
  • 17:17especially as a child,
  • 17:19or have had radiation exposure.
  • 17:20And who another risk factor would be
  • 17:23having a family history of thyroid
  • 17:25cancer in a first degree relative.
  • 17:30So I guess the next
  • 17:31question that people ask me,
  • 17:33what do I do when I find a thyroid nodule?
  • 17:36What does the doctor do or what
  • 17:37should they do?
  • 17:39The first thing to do is a blood test,
  • 17:42and in addition to the thyroid
  • 17:43ultrasound that I mentioned and the
  • 17:45blood test is really to see whether
  • 17:47you have a normal amount of thyroid
  • 17:49hormone in your body and that's
  • 17:51done through a test called thyroid
  • 17:53stimulating hormone called TSH.
  • 17:54And so the reason we do that
  • 17:56is that thyroid nodules,
  • 17:57actually some of them can make
  • 17:59thyroid hormone and those
  • 18:00are called hot nodules.
  • 18:02On the other hand,
  • 18:03there are thyroid nodules that
  • 18:04don't make extra thyroid hormone,
  • 18:06and those are the ones that
  • 18:08typically need to be more evaluated
  • 18:10for whether they are cancerous or not.
  • 18:13So if somebody has a test that
  • 18:15shows that their thyroid
  • 18:17hormone levels are very high,
  • 18:19then it's very unlikely for that
  • 18:20thyroid nodule to be cancer,
  • 18:22and in that case
  • 18:24it's not something that's biopsied.
  • 18:25However, if you find a cold nodule,
  • 18:28what we do is a thyroid ultrasound.
  • 18:30We look at the ultrasound to see
  • 18:32what does this nodule look like.
  • 18:34Are there things in the nodule
  • 18:36that are more concerning?
  • 18:37For example,
  • 18:38sometimes tiny bits of calcium can
  • 18:40be seen in the nodule and that can be
  • 18:42very classic for papillary thyroid cancer.
  • 18:44So in those cases we're more
  • 18:47concerned will offer the patient a
  • 18:48biopsy which is done with a very
  • 18:50fine needle where only cells are
  • 18:52removed from the thyroid nodule and
  • 18:54then looked at under the microscope.
  • 18:58You mentioned some of the risk factors
  • 19:01are radiation,
  • 19:03especially and
  • 19:05other inherited susceptibilities.
  • 19:06I guess what I'm really asking
  • 19:08is who should be screened?
  • 19:11Or should screening be done on a
  • 19:13routine basis for thyroid nodules?
  • 19:15So I would
  • 19:16say that screening just doing ultrasounds
  • 19:19on everybody should not be done.
  • 19:21I believe that if that's done there would
  • 19:24be a lot of patients who would have
  • 19:28unnecessary biopsies
  • 19:28potentially and tiny tiny
  • 19:30thyroid cancers being found that really
  • 19:32may not have caused the patient any trouble.
  • 19:35So generally speaking,
  • 19:36if a nodule is palpated on exam,
  • 19:39so having good physical exams at
  • 19:41your annual physical is important.
  • 19:42If something is found there, then yes,
  • 19:45thyroid ultrasound should be performed.
  • 19:47Or if one of the thyroid cancers that we
  • 19:49didn't really talk about much today but
  • 19:52is called medullary thyroid cancer,
  • 19:54and that one can run in families,
  • 19:56meaning that it can be passed
  • 19:58on from parent to child.
  • 20:00And
  • 20:01is often due to a genetic mutation
  • 20:03that can be checked for in
  • 20:05those types of families, yes,
  • 20:07thyroid ultrasound would be indicated,
  • 20:09but in the general public,
  • 20:10I wouldn't say at a specific age
  • 20:12that people should
  • 20:14just generally be screened.
  • 20:16I think that would be finding too many
  • 20:18and there would be too many
  • 20:20unnecessary procedures.
  • 20:21I'm aware
  • 20:21of a Korean study,
  • 20:23and apparently the conclusion
  • 20:24was they went through the roof with
  • 20:26finding so many thyroid nodules,
  • 20:28so we don't need to do that.
  • 20:30I think that's a
  • 20:31perfect example of what you just said.
  • 20:34Another controversy seems to be
  • 20:36regarding these indeterminant fine
  • 20:38needle aspiration biopsies. Can you
  • 20:40discuss that for us? It seems like
  • 20:42it's around 25% or so of biopsy is
  • 20:45a significant number of patients so
  • 20:47so let me walk you through a biopsy.
  • 20:49If I send you for a biopsy and you
  • 20:52had this aspiration biopsy
  • 20:54the results can be one of the following
  • 20:58so they can come back and say
  • 21:01this is most likely benign.
  • 21:04Two, they can come back and
  • 21:05say, this is most likely cancer.
  • 21:07And then there's this whole gray
  • 21:09area in between of what you've
  • 21:11described called indeterminate.
  • 21:13It's very frustrating both
  • 21:14for patients and providers.
  • 21:15What does that mean?
  • 21:16How much percentage risk of cancer is that?
  • 21:19It's a large range and so
  • 21:21management can be difficult if you
  • 21:23just get this intermediate result.
  • 21:25So over the past couple of years,
  • 21:27what's been developed is called
  • 21:29molecular testing,
  • 21:29where they take the RNA or the ribo
  • 21:32nucleic acid from these cells that
  • 21:34you have taken from the biopsy.
  • 21:36And actually test that for different
  • 21:38mutations or changes that
  • 21:40are typically seen in thyroid cancer.
  • 21:42If those are seen than the results
  • 21:44can come back and say,
  • 21:46you actually have, for example,
  • 21:48of 40% risk of cancer,
  • 21:50not a 15% risk of cancer in
  • 21:52that indeterminate category,
  • 21:53and that can sway you and say,
  • 21:56you know what?
  • 21:57This makes more sense to take the patient
  • 22:00to surgery or offer them a thyroid surgery,
  • 22:02at least for that side of the thyroid
  • 22:05as opposed to watching that nodule, so
  • 22:08this molecular testing has been
  • 22:10very helpful in guiding us in
  • 22:12managing these patients,
  • 22:13but yes,
  • 22:13a very frustrating result
  • 22:15when you get that gray,
  • 22:16area result.
  • 22:18Do you find the patients tend to
  • 22:20lean more towards surgery
  • 22:22then follow up because of this
  • 22:25uncertainty about the
  • 22:26nature of the nodules.
  • 22:29It varies. I've had both ends of the
  • 22:31spectrum more so I would say more of
  • 22:34my patients would be more
  • 22:36proactive.
  • 22:38I don't want to categorize people,
  • 22:40but there are patients also who are
  • 22:43very conservative and maybe with more
  • 22:45advanced age with other risk factors for
  • 22:47surgery they may want to just watch it
  • 22:50and I think that makes sense
  • 22:51if you have other reasons,
  • 22:53severe heart disease or heart failure.
  • 22:55Other things that may increase your
  • 22:57risk of complications post operatively,
  • 22:59then it would make sense to watch them,
  • 23:02especially if your risk
  • 23:03ends up being low.
  • 23:05Let's move on and let me ask
  • 23:08you this, what is endocrinology?
  • 23:10What is the role that hormones play and
  • 23:14how is that managed and what does the
  • 23:16thyroid do?
  • 23:19You're an endocrinologist.
  • 23:21What exactly do you do?
  • 23:24Endocrinology is a study of the body's
  • 23:26endocrine system, which is basically
  • 23:28the system that controls your hormones,
  • 23:30and this includes the pancreas,
  • 23:32the thyroid, parathyroid,
  • 23:33the parathyroid and thyroid in your neck.
  • 23:36The hypothalamus and pituitary which are
  • 23:38in your brain and adrenal glands
  • 23:41I like to say sit on top of the
  • 23:45kidneys are like little hats on the kidneys.
  • 23:48In addition to that, sex hormones
  • 23:50are made by the testes and ovaries.
  • 23:53So as an endocrinologist I manage diseases
  • 23:55that involve the endocrine system,
  • 23:57including thyroid disorders,
  • 23:58osteoporosis and bone diseases,
  • 23:59diabetes, pituitary disease,
  • 24:00and even transgender medicine.
  • 24:03You mentioned a lot of
  • 24:05organs that are now sometimes
  • 24:07affected by our newer medications.
  • 24:10We have targeted therapy and a lot
  • 24:12of the new checkpoint inhibitors,
  • 24:15for instance, affect these organs.
  • 24:17Can you talk a little bit about that?
  • 24:21Definitely,
  • 24:21so we've had a lot of rules over
  • 24:23the last few years as those
  • 24:26immunotherapy's have been used and these
  • 24:28immunotherapies are basically tricking
  • 24:31your body's immune system to attacking
  • 24:33the cancer and it works really well.
  • 24:36But actually also tends to attack
  • 24:38these glands that I treat so quite
  • 24:40often I will see patients who are
  • 24:42getting these treatments and will have
  • 24:45what we call thyrotoxicosis or too
  • 24:47much thyroid hormone because the
  • 24:49thyroid gland is being attacked by
  • 24:52the agents. In addition to that,
  • 24:54you can actually see also
  • 24:55inflammation of your pituitary gland,
  • 24:57which is the gland which is a tiny
  • 24:59gland in the middle of your brain
  • 25:01and we call it actually the master
  • 25:04gland because it sends out
  • 25:06hormones to other parts of your
  • 25:08body and glands to control those.
  • 25:11The beauty though is that we never tell
  • 25:13oncologists
  • 25:15to stop their treatment.
  • 25:16The beauty of it is that we
  • 25:18have all the hormones to replace
  • 25:20that in terms of treatment.
  • 25:22So whatever needs to be done
  • 25:24for their primary cancer,
  • 25:25we say go on and do what you need
  • 25:28to do and we will take care
  • 25:30of this equality that happens with
  • 25:32the hormones and we will replace
  • 25:34whatever hormones needed to
  • 25:36be replaced so the thyroid,
  • 25:37in my experience, can be both
  • 25:39overactive as you just mentioned,
  • 25:41but also under active.
  • 25:42So you need to be able to evaluate that.
  • 25:47One of the reasons I love endocrinology
  • 25:50is that we can check blood work
  • 25:52and blood work can be very helpful
  • 25:55in telling you what is going on.
  • 25:58So one of the things
  • 25:59that can happen is inflammation,
  • 26:02or thyroiditis of the
  • 26:03thyroid gland can happen with
  • 26:05these immune checkpoint inhibitors.
  • 26:07So initially what happens with them
  • 26:09is inflammation of the gland and there
  • 26:11is actually a thyroid hormone
  • 26:13within the gland that as it's attacked is
  • 26:16released and so because that happens,
  • 26:18there's a lot of extra thyroid hormone
  • 26:20in the body and patients can feel
  • 26:23symptoms of too much thyroid hormone.
  • 26:25What would those be?
  • 26:27Feeling hot when no one else is hot.
  • 26:30Almost like a hot flash feeling
  • 26:32very hungry and actually having weight loss.
  • 26:35You can have weight gain, just an
  • 26:38imbalance in your thyroid
  • 26:40hormone after that happens because
  • 26:42the thyroid gland has been inflamed.
  • 26:44It also can no longer make
  • 26:47thyroid hormone,
  • 26:48so a lot of
  • 26:51thyroid hormone patients go through
  • 26:52a state of
  • 26:56very low thyroid hormone and so
  • 26:58at that point the thyroid hormone
  • 27:00needs to be replaced,
  • 27:02and so that's a very typical
  • 27:04picture that we see.
  • 27:06We call immunotherapy related.
  • 27:07It's like a thyroiditis and the
  • 27:09symptoms of low thyroid.
  • 27:12And you can see the opposite
  • 27:14so you can feel very tired.
  • 27:17Feel cold when no one else is cold,
  • 27:19constipated. And you can
  • 27:21also have a low heart rate.
  • 27:24We're just about ready
  • 27:25to finish. But let me ask you are there any
  • 27:28recent advances that have been made or
  • 27:30exciting research in the pipeline?
  • 27:32You alluded to some of that.
  • 27:34Actually, immunotherapy is being used now
  • 27:36in trials to see whether that can help
  • 27:38patients with advanced thyroid cancer.
  • 27:40And at Yale, there is a trial
  • 27:42now ongoing with cabozantinib,
  • 27:44which is a tyrosine kinase inhibitor in
  • 27:46patients who have failed another type of
  • 27:48tyrosine kinase inhibitor called Lynn VAT,
  • 27:50and if so, a lot of interesting
  • 27:52research is going on in advanced
  • 27:54thyroid cancer these days.
  • 27:56Doctor Grace Lee is an assistant
  • 27:58professor in the section of
  • 28:00endocrinology and metabolism at
  • 28:02the Yale School of Medicine.
  • 28:04If you have questions,
  • 28:05the address is canceranswers@yale.edu
  • 28:07and past editions of the program
  • 28:09are available in audio and written
  • 28:11form at Yalecancercenter.org.
  • 28:12We hope you'll join us next week to
  • 28:14learn more about the fight against
  • 28:17cancer here on Connecticut public radio.